Thalmann Urs
Anthropological Institute, University Zürich-Irchel, and Jane Goodall Institute, Zürich, Switzerland.
Folia Primatol (Basel). 2007;78(5-6):420-43. doi: 10.1159/000105153. Epub 2007 Sep 7.
The lemurs of Madagascar represent a spectacular example of adaptive radiation among primates. Given the special setting under which they evolved (i.e. long isolation, geographical location, geological relief), they provide excellent models for study in many realms, and at different levels and scales, including diversity. At the same time, they occur in a 'hottest hot spot' region for biodiversity conservation. Although there is no single definition of biodiversity, the most commonly used units to measure biodiversity are species-species richness, species abundance and, for conservation purposes in particular, species endemism. However, what a species actually is or how, precisely, it should be defined are unresolved issues. Many species concepts have been proposed and several have been used in primatology in recent years. Nowadays, one of the more common approaches to measuring diversity, and eventually inferring species status, is to look at genetic diversity as reflected by mitochondrial DNA differences. Not enough attention has been paid, however, to the different levels at which genetic differences may occur. Lemurs provide instructive examples to highlight the questions involved in species recognition and definition. Using lemurs as examples, I will highlight the strengths and limitations of some analytical tools, including phylogeography and cladistic biogeography and, I will, in particular, emphasize the questions arising at the interface of scientific and conservation perceptions, both of which influence decisions in the field of biodiversity preservation.
马达加斯加的狐猴是灵长类动物适应性辐射的一个显著例子。鉴于它们进化所处的特殊环境(即长期隔离、地理位置、地质地貌),它们在许多领域、不同层次和尺度上,包括多样性方面,都提供了绝佳的研究模型。同时,它们出现在生物多样性保护的“最热点”地区。尽管生物多样性没有单一的定义,但测量生物多样性最常用的单位是物种——物种丰富度、物种丰度,特别是出于保护目的的物种特有性。然而,一个物种实际上是什么,或者应该如何精确地定义它,这些问题尚未得到解决。近年来已经提出了许多物种概念,其中一些已在灵长类学中得到应用。如今,测量多样性并最终推断物种地位的一种更常见方法是观察线粒体DNA差异所反映的遗传多样性。然而,人们对可能出现遗传差异的不同层面关注不足。狐猴提供了具有启发性的例子,以突出物种识别和定义中涉及的问题。以狐猴为例,我将强调一些分析工具的优势和局限性,包括系统地理学和分支生物地理学,并且我将特别强调在科学认知与保护认知的交叉点上出现的问题,这两者都会影响生物多样性保护领域的决策。