Norlin Chuck, Sharp Adam L, Firth Sean D
Department of Pediatrics, University of Utah Health Sciences Center, Salt Lake City, Utah 84132, USA.
Ambul Pediatr. 2007 Sep-Oct;7(5):396-400. doi: 10.1016/j.ambp.2007.05.008.
To identify the frequency, types, and perceived importance of questions prompted during primary care visits for which pediatricians have no ready answer; to characterize pediatricians' responses to them; and to determine how questions prompted while caring for children with special health care needs (CSHCN) and children without special needs (Cw/oSN) differ.
Patient visits with 35 general pediatricians were observed. Parents completed a CSHCN screener. Physicians provided details about their unanswered questions and their pursuit of answers.
Of 890 observed visits, 170 (19.1%) prompted unanswered questions, of which 60.1% were deemed important or very important. Physicians intended to pursue answers to 49.7% of the questions but actually pursued answers for only 27.5%, citing lack of time and inadequate information resources as barriers. One hundred sixty-seven (18.8%) visits were with CSHCN. Unanswered questions arose more often with CSHCN than with Cw/oSN (28.7% vs 16.9%; odds ratio 1.98; 95% confidence interval, 1.32-2.97), particularly during well visits (34.6% vs 14.9%; odds ratio 3.24; 95% confidence interval, 1.59-6.39). CSHCN prompted more diagnosis and treatment questions than Cw/oSN. Questions prompted by CSHCN were ranked as more important but were no more likely to be pursued than those prompted by Cw/oSN.
Unanswered questions arise during nearly 20% of pediatric primary care visits. Visits with CSHCN, particularly well visits, generate more questions than those with Cw/oSN. Answers are pursued for few unanswered questions, both overall and for CSHCN. Potential strategies to overcome barriers to answering questions include scheduling more time or more visits for CSHCN.
确定在初级保健就诊期间引发的、儿科医生没有现成答案的问题的频率、类型和感知重要性;描述儿科医生对这些问题的应对方式;并确定在照顾有特殊医疗需求的儿童(CSHCN)和无特殊需求的儿童(Cw/oSN)时引发的问题有何不同。
观察了35名普通儿科医生的患者就诊情况。家长完成了一份CSHCN筛查表。医生提供了关于他们未回答问题及其寻求答案情况的详细信息。
在观察的890次就诊中,170次(19.1%)引发了未回答的问题,其中60.1%被认为重要或非常重要。医生打算为49.7%的问题寻求答案,但实际仅为27.5%的问题寻求了答案,称缺乏时间和信息资源不足是障碍。167次(18.8%)就诊涉及CSHCN。CSHCN比Cw/oSN更容易引发未回答的问题(28.7%对16.9%;优势比1.98;95%置信区间,1.32 - 2.97),尤其是在健康检查就诊期间(34.6%对14.9%;优势比3.24;95%置信区间,1.59 - 6.39)。与Cw/oSN相比,CSHCN引发了更多关于诊断和治疗的问题。CSHCN引发的问题被评为更重要,但与Cw/oSN引发的问题相比,寻求答案的可能性并没有更高。
在近20%的儿科初级保健就诊中会出现未回答的问题。与Cw/oSN相比,CSHCN的就诊,尤其是健康检查就诊,会引发更多问题。总体而言,无论是针对所有未回答的问题还是针对CSHCN的问题,寻求答案的情况都很少。克服回答问题障碍的潜在策略包括为CSHCN安排更多时间或更多就诊。