Moret Leila, Nguyen Jean-Michel, Volteau Christelle, Falissard Bruno, Lombrail Pierre, Gasquet Isabelle
Public Health Department, University Hospital of Nantes, Nantes Cedex, France.
Int J Qual Health Care. 2007 Dec;19(6):382-9. doi: 10.1093/intqhc/mzm041. Epub 2007 Sep 14.
Patient age is the main socio-demographic factor influencing patient satisfaction with care but the nature of the relationship between age and patient satisfaction is controversial.
This study aims to clarify whether the association of age with satisfaction is linear or shows some other configuration.
Data were obtained from two different satisfaction studies conducted in 27 short-stay teaching hospitals. Study 1 included 1547 inpatients, who completed the EQS-H questionnaire at the time of discharge. Study 2 included 7624 inpatients interviewed by phone at home after discharge, who answered the SAPHORA questionnaire. On the basis of the results of the exploratory analysis, three models for adjustment of age on satisfaction were compared: a simple linear model, a five-group step function and a linear model with a change in slope.
The most suitable model for adjusting patient age to satisfaction scores for quality of medical and nursing care, whether for the EQS-H or the SAPHORA scale, was not a linear relationship: patient age was linearly and positively correlated to satisfaction before 65 years and negatively thereafter. Adjustment of patient age to accommodation and premises satisfaction scores proved to be different, closer to a linear relationship.
These results suggest considering the patient age variable as a non-linear factor for adjusting satisfaction scores, in particular in relation to care. Further studies are needed to confirm the evidence of a threshold around 65 years beyond which satisfaction scores for the quality of medical and nursing care decrease.
患者年龄是影响患者对医疗护理满意度的主要社会人口统计学因素,但年龄与患者满意度之间关系的本质存在争议。
本研究旨在阐明年龄与满意度之间的关联是线性的还是呈现其他某种形式。
数据来自在27家短期教学医院进行的两项不同的满意度研究。研究1包括1547名住院患者,他们在出院时完成了EQS - H问卷。研究2包括7624名出院后在家中接受电话访谈的住院患者,他们回答了SAPHORA问卷。基于探索性分析的结果,比较了三种年龄对满意度调整的模型:简单线性模型、五组阶梯函数模型和斜率变化的线性模型。
对于EQS - H量表或SAPHORA量表,将患者年龄调整为医疗护理质量满意度得分的最合适模型并非线性关系:65岁之前患者年龄与满意度呈线性正相关,65岁之后呈负相关。将患者年龄调整为住宿和设施满意度得分的情况有所不同,更接近线性关系。
这些结果表明,应将患者年龄变量视为调整满意度得分的非线性因素,尤其是在医疗护理方面。需要进一步研究以证实65岁左右存在一个阈值的证据,超过该阈值,医疗护理质量的满意度得分会下降。