Goldstein Larry B
Department of Medicine (Neurology), Duke Center for Cerebrovascular Disease, Center for Clinical Health Policy Research, Duke University, NC, USA.
Cerebrovasc Dis. 2007;24(5):460-2. doi: 10.1159/000108437. Epub 2007 Sep 19.
Routine chest radiographs at the time of hospital admission are not recommended for stroke patients in the absence of pulmonary symptoms. The usefulness of the test in patients being evaluated by a stroke team for hyperacute stroke symptoms was assessed.
Demographic information, chest radiograph results, and the impact of the test on the emergency department (ED) management of a consecutive series of patients evaluated by a stroke code team between 2005-2006 were retrospectively collected and analyzed.
Chest radiographs were obtained in the ED for 92% of patients (n = 113). The sole indication for the test was 'stroke' in 91% (one patient had a normal study performed for chest pain; the remainder were performed in association with endotracheal intubation). Chest radiographs were completely normal in 70% with 25.2% having incidental and 3.8% having potentially relevant findings. No patient had a finding that otherwise affected their ED management.
Routine chest radiographs obtained as part of the emergent evaluation of patients with acute stroke symptoms rarely provide useful information, expose the patient to unnecessary radiation, add costs, and can interfere with other more critical parts of the patient's emergent assessment.
对于没有肺部症状的中风患者,不建议在入院时进行常规胸部X光检查。本研究评估了该检查对于由中风团队评估的超急性中风症状患者的效用。
回顾性收集并分析了2005年至2006年间由中风急救团队评估的一系列连续患者的人口统计学信息、胸部X光检查结果以及该检查对急诊科(ED)管理的影响。
92%(n = 113)的患者在急诊科进行了胸部X光检查。该检查的唯一指征是“中风”的占91%(一名患者因胸痛进行了正常检查;其余检查与气管插管相关)。胸部X光检查结果完全正常的占70%,有偶然发现的占25.2%,有潜在相关发现的占3.8%。没有患者的检查结果影响其在急诊科的管理。
作为急性中风症状患者紧急评估一部分而进行的常规胸部X光检查很少能提供有用信息,会使患者受到不必要的辐射,增加成本,并可能干扰患者紧急评估的其他更关键部分。