Sagar G, Riley P, Vohrah A
Department of Radiology, City Hospital NHS Trust, Birmingham, UK.
Clin Radiol. 1996 Jul;51(7):499-502. doi: 10.1016/s0009-9260(96)80190-5.
Chest radiographs are frequently requested on admission of patients with a clinical diagnosis of acute stroke. This study assesses their value in subsequent management of these patients. A retrospective analysis of 435 patients with a clinical diagnosis of acute stroke was made. All admission chest radiographs were reviewed to document both radiographic quality and any radiological abnormality. In those patients with an abnormal radiograph, clinical records were reviewed to assess their impact on clinical management. Eighty-six percent of patients had a chest radiograph performed on admission. 77.5% of these films were deemed to be technically unsatisfactory, the commonest problems being positioning and suboptimal inspiration. Radiological abnormality was demonstrated in 61 patients (16.4% of radiographs obtained). Clinical management was altered in 14 of the 61 patients (3.8% of the total number of patients radiographed). Radiological abnormality was missed by the admitting clinicians in four radiographs (1 hilar mass, 2 cases of consolidation, one of pulmonary oedema). One abnormality not clinically suspected was recorded (multiple metastases). We conclude that admission chest radiographs in patients with an acute stroke are not indicated in the absence of appropriate clinical indications.
对于临床诊断为急性卒中的患者,入院时经常会要求进行胸部X光检查。本研究评估了其在这些患者后续治疗中的价值。对435例临床诊断为急性卒中的患者进行了回顾性分析。对所有入院时的胸部X光片进行了复查,以记录X光片质量和任何放射学异常情况。对于X光片异常的患者,查阅临床记录以评估其对临床治疗的影响。86%的患者入院时进行了胸部X光检查。其中77.5%的片子在技术上被认为不满意,最常见的问题是体位和吸气不足。61例患者(占所获取X光片的16.4%)显示有放射学异常。61例患者中有14例(占接受X光检查患者总数的3.8%)的临床治疗发生了改变。住院医生在4张X光片中漏诊了放射学异常(1例肺门肿块、2例实变、1例肺水肿)。记录到1例临床未怀疑的异常情况(多发转移瘤)。我们得出结论,在没有适当临床指征的情况下,急性卒中患者入院时不建议进行胸部X光检查。