Hiraishi Hirotoshi, Hashimoto Toshiaki, Mori Kenji, Ito Hiromichi, Harada Masafumi
Primate Research Institute, Kyoto University, Inuyama, Aichi.
No To Hattatsu. 2007 Sep;39(5):360-5.
Autistic patients show social cognitive disorders and hardly recognize their situations. This means it is difficult for them to obey rules or conform to customs. Humans have social intelligence thought to be related to a network connected to amygdala, the orbito-frontal cortex, and the superior temporal gyrus. It has been reported that normal participants judged morality in dilemma sentences through which the medial orbito-frontal cortex and the right lateral prefrontal cortex were activated. However, where autism is concerned, there has been no fMRI study during the moral judgment task. The study herein showed changes of autistic brain areas related to moral judgment. This study included one high-functioning autistic child, one Asperger's syndrome child, and three normal children. Pictures of social situations were painted and the children present were asked to judge whether the contents were moral or immoral. The results of fMRI demonstrated the orbito-frontal cortex was active in normal children but not active in the autistic children with regard to moral judgment. This suggested autistic people have functional disorders in this area. BA11 and BA22 were activated in the control group and these areas are thought to be related to sociality and "theory of mind". Furthermore, BA38 was activated in one control and this area is also related to "theory of mind" and emotions. Moral judgments about personal affairs activate brain areas related to emotions (bilateral medial frontal gyri, bilateral cingulated gyri and bilateral angular gyri) and moral judgments about public affairs activate brain areas related to working memory (left medial frontal gyrus and bilateral temporal cortices). Based on the results above, we think moral judgment is related to "theory of mind" and social cognition, and shares a common sense processing mechanism. Recently Greene et al. reported that the prefrontal cortex was active during moral judgment in an fMRI study of normally developed people. Their result reinforces our results.
自闭症患者表现出社会认知障碍,几乎无法认清自身处境。这意味着他们很难遵守规则或遵循习俗。人类拥有被认为与连接杏仁核、眶额皮质和颞上回的神经网络相关的社会智力。据报道,正常参与者通过激活内侧眶额皮质和右侧前额叶外侧皮质的两难情境句子来判断道德。然而,就自闭症而言,在道德判断任务期间尚未有功能磁共振成像(fMRI)研究。本文的研究显示了与道德判断相关的自闭症大脑区域的变化。该研究包括一名高功能自闭症儿童、一名阿斯伯格综合征儿童和三名正常儿童。绘制了社会情境图片,并要求在场的儿童判断内容是道德的还是不道德的。功能磁共振成像结果表明,在道德判断方面,眶额皮质在正常儿童中活跃,而在自闭症儿童中不活跃。这表明自闭症患者在该区域存在功能障碍。在对照组中,BA11和BA22被激活,这些区域被认为与社会性和“心理理论”有关。此外,在一名对照组中BA38被激活,该区域也与“心理理论”和情感有关。关于个人事务的道德判断会激活与情感相关的大脑区域(双侧内侧额回、双侧扣带回和双侧角回),而关于公共事务的道德判断会激活与工作记忆相关的大脑区域(左侧内侧额回和双侧颞叶皮质)。基于上述结果,我们认为道德判断与“心理理论”和社会认知有关,并共享一种常识性处理机制。最近,格林等人在一项对正常发育人群的功能磁共振成像研究中报告说,前额叶皮质在道德判断期间是活跃的。他们的结果强化了我们的结果。