Chan A, Isbister G K, Kirkpatrick C M J, Dufful S B
School of Pharmacy, University of Queensland, Brisbane, Australia.
QJM. 2007 Oct;100(10):609-15. doi: 10.1093/qjmed/hcm072. Epub 2007 Sep 19.
Although QT prolongation is associated with increased risk of torsade de pointes (TdP), the precise relationship is not well defined.
To evaluate the performance of a QT nomogram in assessing the risk of TdP from QT-RR combinations.
Systematic review.
We systematically searched MEDLINE/EMBASE for cases of drug-induced TdP. Controls were patients taking non-cardiotoxic drugs in overdose. Inclusion criteria were definite TdP, normal ECG before or after the event, association with a drug/toxin and QT-RR measurements available. The upper bound of a QT-RR cloud diagram developed from human preclinical studies was converted into a QT nomogram [QT vs. heart rate (HR)]. QT-HR combinations for TdP cases and controls were plotted with the QT nomogram, and curves corresponding to a QTc = 440 ms and QTc = 500 ms for comparison (Bazett's correction).
We identified 129 cases of TdP. TdP cases occurred at lower HR values with longer QT intervals, with most cases occurring at HR 30-90 bpm. Controls were more evenly distributed, with HR 40-160 bpm. The sensitivity and specificity of the QT nomogram were 96.9% (95%CI 93.9-99.9) and 98.7% (95%CI 96.8-100), respectively. For Bazett QTc = 440 ms, sensitivity and specificity were 98.5% (95%CI 96.3-100) and 66.7% (95%CI 58.6-74.7), respectively, whereas for Bazett QTc =500 ms they were 93.8% (95%CI 89.6-98.0) and 97.2% (95%CI 94.3-100), respectively.
The QT nomogram is a clinically relevant risk assessment tool that accurately predicts arrhythmogenic risk for drug-induced QT prolongation. Further prospective evaluation of the nomogram is needed.
虽然QT间期延长与尖端扭转型室速(TdP)风险增加相关,但确切关系尚不明确。
评估QT列线图在根据QT-RR组合评估TdP风险方面的性能。
系统评价。
我们系统检索MEDLINE/EMBASE以查找药物诱导的TdP病例。对照为过量服用非心脏毒性药物的患者。纳入标准为明确的TdP、事件前后心电图正常、与药物/毒素相关且有QT-RR测量值。将从人体临床前研究得出的QT-RR云图的上限转换为QT列线图[QT与心率(HR)]。将TdP病例和对照的QT-HR组合绘制在QT列线图上,并绘制对应于校正QTc = 440 ms和QTc = 500 ms的曲线进行比较(Bazett校正)。
我们确定了129例TdP病例。TdP病例发生在心率较低且QT间期较长时,大多数病例发生在心率30 - 90次/分钟。对照分布更均匀,心率为40 - 160次/分钟。QT列线图的敏感性和特异性分别为96.9%(95%CI 93.9 - 99.9)和98.7%(95%CI 96.8 - 100)。对于Bazett QTc = 440 ms,敏感性和特异性分别为98.5%(95%CI 96.3 - 100)和66.7%(95%CI 58.6 - 74.7),而对于Bazett QTc = 500 ms,它们分别为93.8%(95%CI 89.6 - 98.0)和97.2%(95%CI 94.3 - 100)。
QT列线图是一种临床相关的风险评估工具,可准确预测药物诱导的QT间期延长的致心律失常风险。需要对该列线图进行进一步的前瞻性评估。