Roberts Martin, Cootes Tim, Pacheco Elisa, Adams Judith
Department of Imaging Science, Stopford Building, University of Manchester, Manchester M13 9PT, United Kingdom.
Acad Radiol. 2007 Oct;14(10):1166-78. doi: 10.1016/j.acra.2007.06.012.
Current quantitative morphometric methods of vertebral fracture detection lack specificity, particularly with mild fractures. We use more detailed shape and texture information to develop quantitative classifiers.
The detailed shape and appearance of vertebrae on 360 lateral dual energy x-ray absorptiometry scans were statistically modeled, thus producing a set of shape and appearance parameters for each vertebra. The vertebrae were given a "gold standard" classification using a consensus reading by two radiologists. Linear discriminants were trained on the vertebral shape and appearance parameters.
The appearance-based classifiers gave significantly better specificity than shape-based methods in all regions of the spine (overall specificity 92% at a sensitivity of 95%), while using the full shape parameters slightly improved specificity in the thoracic spine compared with using three standard height ratios. The main improvement was in the detection of mild fractures. Performance varied over different regions of the spine. False-positive rates at 95% sensitivity for the lumbar, mid-thoracic (T12-T10) and upper thoracic (T9-T7) regions were 2.9%, 14.6%, and 5.5%, respectively, compared with 6.4%, 32.6%, and 21.1% for three-height morphometry.
The appearance and shape parameters of statistical models could provide more powerful quantitative classifiers of osteoporotic vertebral fracture, particularly mild fractures. False positive rates can be substantially reduced at high sensitivity by using an appearance-based classifier, because this can better distinguish between mild fractures and some kinds of non-fracture shape deformities.
当前用于检测椎体骨折的定量形态测量方法缺乏特异性,尤其是对于轻度骨折。我们使用更详细的形状和纹理信息来开发定量分类器。
对360例腰椎双能X线吸收测定扫描图像上椎体的详细形状和外观进行统计建模,从而为每个椎体生成一组形状和外观参数。由两名放射科医生通过共识解读为椎体给出“金标准”分类。基于椎体形状和外观参数训练线性判别模型。
在脊柱的所有区域,基于外观的分类器比基于形状的方法具有显著更高的特异性(在灵敏度为95%时,总体特异性为92%),与使用三个标准高度比相比,使用完整形状参数可使胸椎的特异性略有提高。主要改进在于轻度骨折的检测。性能在脊柱的不同区域有所差异。在灵敏度为95%时,腰椎、中胸椎(T12 - T10)和上胸椎(T9 - T7)区域的假阳性率分别为2.9%、14.6%和5.5%,而三高度形态测量法的假阳性率分别为6.4%、32.6%和21.1%。
统计模型的外观和形状参数可为骨质疏松性椎体骨折,尤其是轻度骨折,提供更强大的定量分类器。通过使用基于外观的分类器,在高灵敏度下可大幅降低假阳性率,因为它能更好地区分轻度骨折和某些类型的非骨折形状畸形。