Harding Kathryn, Galano Joseph, Martin Joanne, Huntington Lee, Schellenbach Cynthia J
Prevent Child Abuse America, Chicago, IL 60611, USA.
J Prev Interv Community. 2007;34(1-2):149-79. doi: 10.1300/J005v34n01_08.
This paper reviews 33 evaluations of Healthy Families America sites, with emphasis on 15 studies that include a control or comparison group. Outcome domains include child health and development, maternal life course, parenting, and child maltreatment. Parenting outcomes (e.g., parenting attitudes) show the most consistent positive impacts. Mixed results in other domains indicate the need for in-depth research to identify factors associated with better outcomes. Several factors that may contribute to differences in outcomes are discussed, including site implementation and quality, differences in family risk levels, and recent augmentations to program design. The paper also highlights two large-scale evaluations, one community-wide (Hampton, Virginia) and one statewide (Indiana), to illustrate exemplary evaluation approaches found in HFA research. Overall, HFA's continuing evolution has been positively impacted by researcher-practitioner partnerships.
本文回顾了对“美国健康家庭”项目点的33项评估,重点关注其中15项包含对照组或比较组的研究。结果领域包括儿童健康与发展、母亲生活历程、育儿以及儿童虐待。育儿结果(如育儿态度)显示出最一致的积极影响。其他领域的结果参差不齐,表明需要进行深入研究以确定与更好结果相关的因素。讨论了几个可能导致结果差异的因素,包括项目点的实施情况和质量、家庭风险水平的差异以及项目设计的近期改进。本文还重点介绍了两项大规模评估,一项是全社区范围的(弗吉尼亚州汉普顿),另一项是全州范围的(印第安纳州),以说明在“美国健康家庭”研究中发现的典范性评估方法。总体而言,研究人员与从业者的合作对“美国健康家庭”项目的持续发展产生了积极影响。