McCarthy Joseph C, Lee Jo-Ann
New England Baptist Hospital, Boston, MA, USA.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2007 Dec;465:166-9. doi: 10.1097/BLO.0b013e318159cb97.
We retrospectively reviewed 87 patients (92 hips) who had revision hip surgery to determine whether a proximally coated, modular femoral component would remain stably fixed at long-term followup. Thirteen patients died and 12 patients were lost to followup leaving 62 patients (67 hips) available for review with minimum followup of 8 years (mean, 14 years; range, 8-17 years). Preoperative radiographs were reviewed using Paprosky's classification. Postoperative radiographs were reviewed for osteolysis, endosteal hypertrophy, cortical hypertrophy, distal pedestals, component breakage, and loosening. Thirty-seven hips underwent femoral allografting, 10 of which were proximal femurs. With revision as the endpoint the Kaplan-Meier survivorship (including deaths and loss to followup) was 60% at 14 years. Forty-seven of the 57 (82%) noncemented stems were bone ingrown. All had relative proximal bone preservation and 33 of 57 (58%) had bone hypertrophy in the diaphysis around zones 2 and 6. There were five aseptic failures (9%). Each of those was Paprosky Class IIIB or IV preoperatively. There were no long-term failures in Paprosky Class II or IIIA. The aseptic failures have been re-revised. This modular stem resulted in reliable fixation with relative preservation of proximal bone stock at this intermediate interval in complex revisions in Paprosky Class II and IIIA. Paprosky Class IIIB and IV defects may need additional component fixation options.
我们回顾性研究了87例(92髋)接受髋关节翻修手术的患者,以确定近端涂层的模块化股骨假体在长期随访中是否能保持稳定固定。13例患者死亡,12例患者失访,剩余62例患者(67髋)可供评估,最短随访时间为8年(平均14年;范围8 - 17年)。术前X线片采用Paprosky分类法进行评估。术后X线片评估骨溶解、骨内膜增厚、皮质增厚、远端骨桥、假体断裂和松动情况。37髋进行了股骨同种异体骨移植,其中10髋为近端股骨。以翻修为终点,Kaplan - Meier生存率(包括死亡和失访)在14年时为60%。57例非骨水泥型股骨柄中有47例(82%)实现骨长入。所有病例均相对保留了近端骨质,57例中有33例(58%)在2区和6区周围的骨干出现骨质增生。有5例无菌性失败(9%)。这些病例术前均为Paprosky IIIB或IV级。Paprosky II级或IIIA级未出现长期失败病例。无菌性失败病例已再次翻修。在Paprosky II级和IIIA级复杂翻修的这个中期阶段,这种模块化股骨柄实现了可靠固定,并相对保留了近端骨量。Paprosky IIIB级和IV级缺损可能需要额外的假体固定选择。