González Esther G, Tarita-Nistor Luminita, Markowitz Samuel N, Steinbach Martin J
Vision Science Research Program, Toronto Western Hospital, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 2007 Oct;48(10):4838-45. doi: 10.1167/iovs.06-1240.
The authors present a computer-based method for evaluating the visual acuity of patients with age-related macular degeneration (AMD). It incorporates four features known to improve visual acuity: high contrast, white optotypes on a black background to reduce intraocular scatter, proportional layout to reduce the effects of crowding, and multiple optotypes to minimize the effects of fixation instability and to maximize the likelihood of optotype detection.
Experiment 1 evaluated the best-eye acuity of 24 patients with AMD using the ETDRS chart and three versions of the Tumbling E acuity test: multiple black optotypes on a white background, single white optotype on a black background, and multiple white optotypes on a black background. Experiment 2 compared the two White E optotype tests with the ETDRS in patients with AMD, and Experiment 3 measured probability summation in persons with normal vision.
Multiple white optotypes on a black background yielded the highest acuity estimates and the ETDRS the lowest. The Single E test yielded a lower estimate of acuity than the two Multiple E tests. The effect of polarity-white on black was better than black on white-was consistent with results found in persons with healthy retinas. For patients with AMD, acuity measured with the Multiple E test was independent of that measured with the ETDRS, but acuity measured with the Single E test decreased as acuity worsened. For the participants with normal vision, the differences between the Multiple and Single E tests were within the known limits of test-retest variability.
The multiple-optotype, reversed-polarity test provides a measure of the optimal visual acuity of which a person is capable and, in this sense, may be a useful tool for assessing rehabilitation progress.
作者提出一种基于计算机的方法,用于评估年龄相关性黄斑变性(AMD)患者的视力。该方法纳入了四个已知可提高视力的特征:高对比度、黑色背景上的白色视标以减少眼内散射、比例布局以减少拥挤效应以及多个视标以最小化注视不稳定的影响并最大化视标检测的可能性。
实验1使用ETDRS视力表和三种版本的翻转E视力测试评估了24例AMD患者的最佳眼视力:白色背景上的多个黑色视标、黑色背景上的单个白色视标以及黑色背景上的多个白色视标。实验2比较了AMD患者中两种白色E视标测试与ETDRS视力表,实验3测量了正常视力者的概率总和。
黑色背景上的多个白色视标得出的视力估计值最高,而ETDRS视力表得出的最低。单个E测试得出的视力估计值低于两个多个E测试。白色对黑色的极性效应优于黑色对白色,这与健康视网膜人群的结果一致。对于AMD患者,使用多个E测试测量的视力与使用ETDRS测量的视力无关,但使用单个E测试测量的视力随着视力恶化而降低。对于正常视力的参与者,多个E测试和单个E测试之间的差异在已知的重测变异性范围内。
多视标、反极性测试提供了一种衡量一个人所能达到的最佳视力的方法,从这个意义上说,它可能是评估康复进展的有用工具。