McGhee Gerry, Marland Glenn R, Atkinson Jacqueline
School of Health Studies, Bell College, Hamilton, UK.
J Adv Nurs. 2007 Nov;60(3):334-42. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2648.2007.04436.x.
AIM: This paper is a report of a discussion of the arguments surrounding the role of the initial literature review in grounded theory. BACKGROUND: Researchers new to grounded theory may find themselves confused about the literature review, something we ourselves experienced, pointing to the need for clarity about use of the literature in grounded theory to help guide others about to embark on similar research journeys. DISCUSSION: The arguments for and against the use of a substantial topic-related initial literature review in a grounded theory study are discussed, giving examples from our own studies. The use of theoretically sampled literature and the necessity for reflexivity are also discussed. Reflexivity is viewed as the explicit quest to limit researcher effects on the data by awareness of self, something seen as integral both to the process of data collection and the constant comparison method essential to grounded theory. CONCLUSION: A researcher who is close to the field may already be theoretically sensitized and familiar with the literature on the study topic. Use of literature or any other preknowledge should not prevent a grounded theory arising from the inductive-deductive interplay which is at the heart of this method. Reflexivity is needed to prevent prior knowledge distorting the researcher's perceptions of the data.
目的:本文报告了关于扎根理论中初始文献综述作用的相关争论的讨论情况。 背景:刚接触扎根理论的研究者可能会对文献综述感到困惑,我们自己就有过这样的经历,这表明有必要明确扎根理论中文献的使用,以帮助指导即将踏上类似研究之旅的其他人。 讨论:讨论了在扎根理论研究中支持和反对进行大量与主题相关的初始文献综述的论点,并给出了我们自己研究中的例子。还讨论了理论抽样文献的使用以及反思性的必要性。反思性被视为通过自我认知明确寻求限制研究者对数据的影响,这在数据收集过程以及扎根理论所必需的持续比较方法中都被视为不可或缺的部分。 结论:接近该领域的研究者可能已经在理论上具有敏感性并且熟悉关于研究主题的文献。文献或任何其他先验知识的使用不应妨碍通过归纳 - 演绎相互作用产生扎根理论,而这种相互作用是该方法的核心。需要反思性来防止先验知识扭曲研究者对数据的认知。
J Adv Nurs. 2007-11
J Clin Nurs. 2009-8
Scand J Caring Sci. 2004-9
Int J Nurs Pract. 2006-2
Health Care Women Int. 2002-12
J Genet Couns. 2025-6
BMC Med Educ. 2022-11-7
Front Artif Intell. 2022-10-12