Lazarowski Alberto, Czornyj Liliana, Lubienieki Fabiana, Girardi Elena, Vazquez Silvia, D'Giano Carlos
Clinical Biochemistry Department, School of Pharmacy and Biochemistry, University of Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina.
Epilepsia. 2007;48 Suppl 5:140-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1528-1167.2007.01302.x.
It is estimated 20-25% of the epileptic patients fails to achieve good control with the different antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) treatments, developing refractory epilepsy (RE). Discovered first in cancer, the activity of P-glycoprotein (P-gp) and others ABC transporters as multidrug-resistance-associated proteins (MRPs) and breast cancer resistant protein (BCRP) are directly related with the refractoriness. We have observed the overexpression of these all transporters in the brain of patients with RE, and according with other authors, all these data suggests an active drug efflux from brain. Both constitutive and seizure induced brain P-gp overexpression was also suggested. As confirmation of these clinical evidences, different models of experimental epilepsy have demonstrated P-gp overexpression on blood brain barrier (BBB) and brain parenchyma cells, as astrocytes and neurons. In our model, early P-pg detection in vessel-related cells and later additional P-gp detection in neurons, correlated with the gradual loss of protective effect of phenytoin. The progressive neuronal P-gp expression, depending on intensity and time-constancy of seizure-injury, was in agreement with the development of "P-gp-positive seizure-axis" proposed by Kwan & Brodie, who also showed that the development of RE directly correlated with the number and frequency of seizures before initiation of drug therapy. P-gp expression in excretory organs suggests that P-gp have a central role in drug elimination. Persistent low levels of AEDs in plasma and P-gp brain overexpression in several RE pediatric patients were reported. We also observed in adult RE patients, an increased liver clearance of 99mTc-hexakis-2-methoxyisobutylisonitrile (99mTc-MIBI) (a P-gp substrate), and the surgically treated cases showed P-gp brain overexpression. These results suggest the systemic hyperactivity of P-gp in RE patients, including brain P-gp over-expression should be suspected when persistent subtherapeutic levels of AEDs in plasma are detected. P-gp neuronal expression described in both clinical and experimental reports indicates that additional mechanisms could be operative from seizure-affected P-gp-positive neurons, due to AEDs targets are expressed at membrane level. An alternative mechanism was demonstrated in P-gp-expressed cells that exhibit lower membrane potential (Deltapsi(0)=-10 to -20) compared to normal physiological Deltapsi(0) of -60 mV. Under this situation and irrespective to the P-gp pharmacoresistant property or type of drug treatment selected, P-gp-expressed neurons could increase their sensitivity to new seizures perhaps as an epileptogenic mechanism. The understanding of properties of these ABC transporters can offer new tools for better selection of more effective preventive or therapeutic strategies and avoid the invasive surgical treatments for RE.
据估计,20%-25%的癫痫患者使用不同的抗癫痫药物(AEDs)治疗后未能实现良好控制,从而发展为难治性癫痫(RE)。P-糖蛋白(P-gp)以及其他ABC转运蛋白如多药耐药相关蛋白(MRPs)和乳腺癌耐药蛋白(BCRP)的活性首先在癌症中被发现,它们与难治性直接相关。我们观察到这些转运蛋白在RE患者大脑中均有过表达,并且与其他作者的观点一致,所有这些数据表明药物从大脑中主动外排。同时也提示了P-gp的组成性和癫痫发作诱导的大脑过表达。作为这些临床证据的佐证,不同的实验性癫痫模型已证明血脑屏障(BBB)以及脑实质细胞如星形胶质细胞和神经元上P-gp过表达。在我们的模型中,血管相关细胞中早期检测到P-pg,随后在神经元中额外检测到P-gp,这与苯妥英保护作用的逐渐丧失相关。神经元P-gp的逐渐表达,取决于癫痫发作损伤的强度和时间持续性,这与Kwan和Brodie提出的“P-gp阳性癫痫轴”的发展一致,他们还表明RE的发展与药物治疗开始前癫痫发作的次数和频率直接相关。排泄器官中P-gp的表达表明P-gp在药物消除中起核心作用。有报道称,一些RE儿科患者血浆中AEDs持续低水平且大脑中P-gp过表达。我们在成年RE患者中也观察到,99m锝-六甲氧基异丁基异腈(99mTc-MIBI)(一种P-gp底物)的肝脏清除率增加,并且手术治疗的病例显示大脑中P-gp过表达。这些结果提示RE患者中P-gp的全身活性增强,当检测到血浆中AEDs持续低于治疗水平时,应怀疑大脑中P-gp过表达。临床和实验报告中描述的P-gp神经元表达表明,由于AEDs靶点在膜水平表达,癫痫发作影响的P-gp阳性神经元可能存在其他作用机制。在表达P-gp的细胞中发现了一种替代机制,与正常生理膜电位-60 mV相比,这些细胞表现出较低的膜电位(Deltapsi(0)= -10至-20)。在这种情况下,无论P-gp的耐药特性或所选药物治疗类型如何,表达P-gp的神经元可能会增加对新癫痫发作的敏感性,这可能是一种致痫机制。了解这些ABC转运蛋白的特性可为更好地选择更有效的预防或治疗策略提供新工具,并避免对RE进行侵入性手术治疗。