Szucs Anna, Fogarasi András, Rásonyi György, Kelemen Anna, Narula Lalit, Tóth Vanda, Janszky József, Halász Péter
Epilepsy Center, National Institute of Psychiatry and Neurology, H-1021 Budapest, Hungary.
Epilepsy Behav. 2007 Dec;11(4):578-81. doi: 10.1016/j.yebeh.2007.07.012. Epub 2007 Oct 1.
Peri-ictal water drinking has been reported to be a lateralizing sign to the right side in temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE). As peri-ictal water drinking is relatively common in our own patients with TLE, we wanted to evaluate its lateralization value for ourselves. We reviewed the data for 55 adult patients with TLE who had undergone epilepsy surgery with a favorable postoperative outcome in our center. Eight patients exhibited peri-ictal water drinking behavior. Five of them had a left temporal and three a right temporal epileptogenic region. We also analyzed cases of peri-ictal water drinking in the literature and found that the reported data do not support this behavior as a laterality indicator. In conclusion, we could not find any evidence for the lateralization value of peri-ictal water drinking in TLE.
据报道,发作期饮水是颞叶癫痫(TLE)中右侧的一种定侧体征。由于发作期饮水在我们自己的TLE患者中相对常见,我们想自行评估其定侧价值。我们回顾了在我们中心接受癫痫手术且术后效果良好的55例成年TLE患者的数据。8例患者表现出发作期饮水行为。其中5例左侧颞叶有癫痫起源区域,3例右侧颞叶有癫痫起源区域。我们还分析了文献中发作期饮水的病例,发现报告的数据不支持这种行为作为定侧指标。总之,我们找不到任何证据支持发作期饮水在TLE中的定侧价值。