Gabel Rodney M, Hughes Stephanie, Daniels Derek
Department of Communication Disorders, Bowling Green State University, Bowling Green, OH 43403, USA.
J Commun Disord. 2008 Mar-Apr;41(2):146-58. doi: 10.1016/j.jcomdis.2007.08.001. Epub 2007 Sep 5.
The primary purpose of this study was to examine whether a group of university students would report role entrapment of people who stutter (PWS) in the form of occupational stereotyping. The study also examined whether severity of stuttering (mild or severe) and level of therapy involvement (choosing or not choosing to attend therapy) affected the perceptions of role entrapment. To examine these issues, 260 students completed the Vocational Advice Scale (VAS) [Gabel, R. M., Blood, G. W., Tellis, G., & Althouse, M. T. (2004). Measuring role entrapment of people who stutter. Journal of Fluency Disorders, 29, 27-49]. Results suggested that stuttering severity and the level of therapy involvement did not appear alter the judges' reports for all of the careers except for the career of speech therapist. For the career of speech therapist, therapy involvement improved the participants' reports and stuttering severity had no effect. Additionally, findings suggested that university students reported that 16 of the careers listed on the VAS were appropriate choices for people who stutter and were less certain about advising for 27 of the careers. Thus, the findings from this study do not support the notion that stuttering leads to role entrapment in the form vocational stereotyping and variations in therapy involvement or stuttering severity do not change perceptions of role entrapment. LEARNER OUTCOMES: The reader will be able to (1) identify common stereotypes of PWS, (2) describe the possible effects of stereotyping and role entrapment, and (3) describe the effects of severity and therapy involvement of role entrapment of PWS.
本研究的主要目的是考察一群大学生是否会以职业刻板印象的形式报告口吃者的角色受限情况。该研究还考察了口吃严重程度(轻度或重度)和治疗参与程度(选择或不选择接受治疗)是否会影响对角色受限的认知。为了研究这些问题,260名学生完成了职业建议量表(VAS)[加贝尔,R.M.,布拉德,G.W.,特利斯,G.,&阿尔特豪斯,M.T.(2004年)。测量口吃者的角色受限情况。《流畅性障碍杂志》,29,27 - 49]。结果表明,除了言语治疗师这一职业外,口吃严重程度和治疗参与程度似乎并未改变评判者对所有职业的报告。对于言语治疗师这一职业,治疗参与改善了参与者的报告,而口吃严重程度则没有影响。此外,研究结果表明,大学生报告称,VAS上列出的16种职业对口吃者来说是合适的选择,而对于27种职业的建议则不太确定。因此,本研究的结果不支持口吃会导致以职业刻板印象形式出现的角色受限这一观点,并且治疗参与程度或口吃严重程度的变化并不会改变对角色受限的认知。学习者成果:读者将能够(1)识别口吃者常见的刻板印象,(2)描述刻板印象和角色受限可能产生的影响,以及(3)描述口吃严重程度和治疗参与程度对口吃者角色受限的影响。