Rhodes Scott D, Foley Kristie Long, Zometa Carlos S, Bloom Fred R
Social Sciences and Health Policy, Wake Forest University Health Sciences, Medical Center Boulevard, Winston-Salem, NC 27157, USA.
Am J Prev Med. 2007 Nov;33(5):418-27. doi: 10.1016/j.amepre.2007.07.023.
With an expanding Hispanic/Latino community in the United States, practitioners and researchers working to promote health and prevent disease have relied on lay health advisor (LHA) models to address a variety of health issues. The primary goal of this systematic review was to explore how LHA approaches have been used and evaluated within Hispanic/Latino communities in the U.S.
Ten literature databases were searched from their inception through July 2006, using keywords associated with LHA approaches. This review consisted of human studies that included adult Hispanics or Latinos of either gender, were conducted in the U.S., were published in English-language peer-reviewed journals, and contained enough abstractable information. Data abstraction was completed independently by three data abstractors using a standardized abstraction form that collected intervention characteristics and study results.
A total of 172 studies were identified and 37 met the inclusion criteria. Of these, 28 included female LHAs exclusively and five included a small number of male as well as female LHAs. Training for LHAs ranged from 6 to 160 hours. Primary roles of LHAs included: supporting participant recruitment and data collection, serving as health advisors and referral sources, distributing materials, being role models, and advocating on behalf of community members. Fourteen studies found evidence of effectiveness.
Given the long history of using LHAs as an approach to health promotion and disease prevention and the current emphasis of LHA approaches as a potential solution to health disparities in general, and among Hispanics/Latinos in particular, few rigorous studies have been published that document the effectiveness of LHAs on a variety of public health concerns. A stronger empirical evidence base is clearly needed.
随着美国西班牙裔/拉丁裔社区的不断扩大,致力于促进健康和预防疾病的从业者和研究人员一直依赖非专业健康顾问(LHA)模式来解决各种健康问题。本系统评价的主要目的是探讨LHA方法在美国西班牙裔/拉丁裔社区中是如何被使用和评估的。
从数据库建立至2006年7月,检索了10个文献数据库,使用了与LHA方法相关的关键词。本评价纳入的研究对象为人类,包括成年的西班牙裔或拉丁裔男性和女性,研究在美国进行,发表于英文同行评审期刊,且包含足够的可提取信息。由三名数据提取员使用标准化提取表独立完成数据提取,该表收集干预特征和研究结果。
共识别出172项研究,37项符合纳入标准。其中,28项仅纳入了女性LHA,5项纳入了少量男性和女性LHA。LHA的培训时长从6小时到160小时不等。LHA的主要职责包括:支持参与者招募和数据收集、担任健康顾问和转诊来源、分发材料、树立榜样以及代表社区成员进行倡导。14项研究发现了有效性证据。
鉴于长期以来使用LHA作为促进健康和预防疾病的方法,以及当前LHA方法被视为解决总体健康差异,特别是西班牙裔/拉丁裔健康差异的潜在解决方案,很少有严谨的研究发表,证明LHA对各种公共卫生问题的有效性。显然需要更有力的实证证据基础。