Díaz Varela R A, Ramil Rego P, Calvo Iglesias S, Muñoz Sobrino C
I.B.A.D.E.R. Departamento de Botánica. GI 1934 TTB, Universidade de Santiago de Compostela, Lugo, Spain.
Environ Monit Assess. 2008 Sep;144(1-3):229-50. doi: 10.1007/s10661-007-9981-y. Epub 2007 Oct 21.
Although remote sensing is increasingly in use for habitat mapping, traditional image classification methods tend to suffer shortcomings due to non-normality of spectral signatures, as well as overlapping and heterogeneity in radiometric responses of natural and semi natural vegetation. Methods using non-parametric classifiers and object-oriented analysis have been suggested as possible solutions for overcoming these limitations. In this paper, we aimed at evaluating the performance of some of these techniques for the European Natura 2000 network of protected areas habitats mapping. For this purpose, we tested different methods of supervised image classification in the Northern Mountains of Galicia, Spain, an area included in the Natura 2000 network, which is characterized by a highly heterogeneous landscape. Methods involved the use of maximum likelihood and nearest neighbour decision rules in per-pixel and per-object classification analyses on Landsat TM imagery. Per-object classifications were completed using the segment mean and segment means plus standard deviation feature spaces. The results showed the existence of significant differences in the accuracies for the different methodologies, their strengths and weaknesses and identified the most adequate approach for habitat mapping. Analyses pointed out that significant improvements in accuracy were achieved only under certain combinations of per-object analysis, non-parametric classifiers and high dimensionality feature space.
尽管遥感技术在栖息地制图中的应用日益广泛,但由于光谱特征的非正态性以及天然和半天然植被辐射响应的重叠性与异质性,传统的图像分类方法往往存在缺陷。有人建议使用非参数分类器和面向对象分析的方法来克服这些限制。在本文中,我们旨在评估其中一些技术在欧洲Natura 2000保护区网络栖息地制图中的性能。为此,我们在西班牙加利西亚北部山区测试了不同的监督图像分类方法,该地区属于Natura 2000网络,其特点是景观高度异质。方法包括在Landsat TM影像的逐像素和逐对象分类分析中使用最大似然法和最近邻决策规则。逐对象分类使用分割均值和分割均值加标准差特征空间来完成。结果表明,不同方法在精度、优缺点方面存在显著差异,并确定了最适合栖息地制图的方法。分析指出,只有在逐对象分析、非参数分类器和高维特征空间的特定组合下,精度才能实现显著提高。