Mahendradhata Yodi, Utarini Adi, Lazuardi Upiek, Boelaert Marleen, Stuyft Patrick Van der
Epidemiology and Disease Control Unit, Public Health Department, Institute of Tropical Medicine, Antwerp, Belgium.
Trop Med Int Health. 2007 Oct;12(10):1218-24. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-3156.2007.01946.x.
Indonesia has a high tuberculosis (TB) prevalence and a large private health sector.
To explore the potential of private practitioners (PP) in TB control in Jogjakarta by assessing their load of TB suspects and case-management practices.
We conducted a cross-sectional telephone survey of a random sample of 164 PP, weighted to the local proportions of specialists, general practitioners (GP), nurses and midwives. We investigated their knowledge of directly observed treatment, short-course (DOTS), whether they see TB suspects, whether they refer such patients and how they possibly diagnose and treat TB.
We sampled 174 PP, of which 164 (94.3%) completed the interview. Most PP (63.4%) reported to have seen TB suspects in their private practice, and 62.8% were also employed in a DOTS facility. Specialists saw on average 18 suspects, GP 11 suspects, and nurses-midwives three suspects in a year. Many PP (45.2%) always relied on National Tuberculosis Control Programme (NTP) services for diagnosis. Fewer PP (41.5%) used, by themselves, diagnostic procedures complying with the NTP guidelines. The majority (63.6%) always referred confirmed cases for treatment, mainly (71.4%) to NTP services. Most PP (72.7%) who treated TB patients themselves did not prescribe the NTP standard regimen.
The study shows that the TB case load per PP is low in Jogjakarta, where the NTP already involves public and private hospitals besides public health centres. Initiatives to engage all PP might only marginally contribute in increasing the TB case detection.
印度尼西亚结核病患病率高,且私营卫生部门规模庞大。
通过评估日惹市私人执业医生(PP)的结核病疑似病例量及病例管理实践,探讨其在结核病控制中的潜力。
我们对164名PP进行了随机抽样的横断面电话调查,根据当地专科医生、全科医生(GP)、护士和助产士的比例进行加权。我们调查了他们对直接观察短程治疗(DOTS)的了解情况,他们是否诊治结核病疑似病例,是否转诊此类患者,以及他们可能如何诊断和治疗结核病。
我们抽取了174名PP作为样本,其中164名(94.3%)完成了访谈。大多数PP(63.4%)报告称在其私人执业中见过结核病疑似病例,62.8%还受雇于一家DOTS机构。专科医生平均每年诊治18名疑似病例,全科医生诊治11名疑似病例,护士和助产士诊治3名疑似病例。许多PP(45.2%)在诊断时总是依赖国家结核病控制规划(NTP)服务。较少的PP(41.5%)自行采用符合NTP指南的诊断程序。大多数(63.6%)总是将确诊病例转诊进行治疗,主要(71.4%)转诊至NTP服务机构。大多数自行治疗结核病患者的PP(72.7%)未开具NTP标准治疗方案。
该研究表明,在日惹市,除了公共卫生中心外,NTP已将公立医院和私立医院纳入其中,每位PP的结核病病例量较低。让所有PP参与的举措对提高结核病病例发现率的贡献可能微乎其微。