Department of Epidemiology, School of Public Health, Airlangga University, Surabaya, Indonesia.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2007 Aug 30;7:135. doi: 10.1186/1472-6963-7-135.
Pulmonary tuberculosis (TB) is a major health problem worldwide. Detection of the most infectious cases of tuberculosis - sputum smear-positive pulmonary cases - by passive case finding is an essential component of TB control. The district of Sidoarjo in East Java reported a low case detection rate (CDR) of 14% in 2003. We evaluated the diagnostic process for TB in primary health care centers (PHC) in Sidoarjo district to assess whether problems in identification of TB suspects or in diagnosing TB patients can explain the low CDR.
We performed interviews with the staff (general nurse, TB worker, laboratory technician, and head of health center) of the 25 PHCs of Sidoarjo district to obtain information about the knowledge of TB, health education practices, and availability of support services for TB diagnosis. The quality of the laboratory diagnosis was examined by providing 10 slides with a known result to the laboratory technicians for re-examination.
Eighty percent of the nurses and 84% of the TB workers knew that cough >3 weeks can be a symptom of TB. Only 40% of the nurses knew the cause of TB, few could mention complications of TB and none could mention the duration of infectiousness after start of treatment. Knowledge of TB workers was much better. Information about how to produce a good sputum sample was provided to TB suspects by 76% of the nurses and 84% of the TB workers. Only few provided all information. Fifty-five percent of the 11 laboratory technicians correctly identified all positive slides as positive and 45% correctly identified 100% of the negative slides as negative. All TB workers, one general nurses and 32% of the laboratory technicians had received specific training in TB control. There has been no shortage of TB forms and laboratory materials in 96% of the PHCs.
The quality of the diagnostic process for TB at PHC in Sidoarjo district should be improved on all levels. Training in TB control of all general nurses and the laboratory technicians that have not received training would be a good first step to enhance diagnosis of TB and to improve the case detection rate.
肺结核(TB)是全球范围内的一个主要健康问题。通过被动病例发现来检测最具传染性的结核病病例 - 痰涂片阳性肺结核病例 - 是结核病控制的重要组成部分。东爪哇省的 Sidoarjo 区在 2003 年报告的病例检出率(CDR)较低,为 14%。我们评估了 Sidoarjo 区初级保健中心(PHC)的结核病诊断过程,以评估是否存在结核病可疑病例识别或结核病患者诊断方面的问题,可以解释低 CDR。
我们对 Sidoarjo 区 25 个 PHC 的工作人员(普通护士、结核病工作者、实验室技术员和卫生中心负责人)进行了访谈,以获取有关结核病知识、健康教育实践以及结核病诊断支持服务的信息。通过向实验室技术员提供 10 张已知结果的幻灯片进行重新检查,检查了实验室诊断的质量。
80%的护士和 84%的结核病工作者知道咳嗽>3 周可能是结核病的症状。只有 40%的护士知道结核病的病因,很少有人能提到结核病的并发症,也没有人能提到治疗开始后传染性的持续时间。结核病工作者的知识要好得多。76%的护士和 84%的结核病工作者向结核病可疑病例提供了如何制作良好痰样的信息。只有少数人提供了所有信息。11 名实验室技术员中的 55%正确识别了所有阳性幻灯片为阳性,45%正确识别了 100%的阴性幻灯片为阴性。所有结核病工作者、一名普通护士和 32%的实验室技术员都接受过结核病控制的专门培训。在 96%的 PHC 中,没有出现过结核病表格和实验室材料短缺的情况。
应该在各个层面上提高 Sidoarjo 区 PHC 的结核病诊断过程的质量。对所有未接受过培训的普通护士和实验室技术员进行结核病控制培训将是提高结核病诊断率和提高病例检出率的良好第一步。