Demir A
Ankara University Cebeci School of Health, Cebeci-Ankara, Turkey.
Int Nurs Rev. 2007 Dec;54(4):367-74. doi: 10.1111/j.1466-7657.2007.00547.x.
This study aimed to determine paediatric nurses' ideas and attitudes towards physical restraint in Turkey, the consent obtained, physical restraint types used in paediatric units and complications developing in children subjected to physical restraint.
Physical restraint, although controversial, is still common in paediatric units in Turkey and creates complications, which were observed or investigated by researchers.
The research used descriptive, analytical and cross-sectional methods with 121 paediatric nurses working in paediatric surgical-internal medicine services and paediatric intensive care units of four hospitals. The questionnaire consisted of open-ended questions and was applied via face-to-face interviews.
66.9% of nurses reported that nurse shortages were the main reason for increased physical restraint applications, 58.7% tried alternative methods, and 71.1% indicated no need of written orders for physical restraint use. Physical restraint decreased while the mother accompanied her child (P = 0.0001) and increased while inexperienced clinic nurses were in charge (P = 0.003). Wrist (96.7%), ankle (81.0%), and whole body (17.4%) restraints were all used. No nurse had received any verbal or written consent from children or surrogates and 96.7% used physical restraint without any verbal or written physician order. Thirty (24.8%) respondents reported that children under physical restraint had developed various complications, for example, oedema and cyanosis by arm and wrist restraint, food rejection and agitation. Physical restraint could be reduced by a wiser combination of education and expert consultation in paediatric units in Turkey, although further detailed research is needed.
本研究旨在确定土耳其儿科护士对身体约束的看法和态度、取得的同意情况、儿科病房使用的身体约束类型以及接受身体约束的儿童出现的并发症。
身体约束尽管存在争议,但在土耳其的儿科病房中仍然很常见,并会引发并发症,研究人员已对这些并发症进行了观察或调查。
本研究采用描述性、分析性和横断面研究方法,对在四家医院的儿科内科 - 外科服务科室及儿科重症监护病房工作的121名儿科护士进行了调查。问卷由开放式问题组成,通过面对面访谈的方式进行发放。
66.9%的护士报告称护士短缺是增加身体约束使用的主要原因,58.7%的护士尝试了替代方法,71.1%的护士表示使用身体约束无需书面医嘱。当母亲陪伴孩子时,身体约束的使用减少(P = 0.0001),而当经验不足的临床护士负责时,身体约束的使用增加(P = 0.003)。手腕约束(96.7%)、脚踝约束(81.0%)和全身约束(17.4%)均有使用。没有护士获得过儿童或替代者的任何口头或书面同意,96.7%的护士在没有任何口头或书面医生医嘱的情况下使用身体约束。30名(24.8%)受访者报告称,接受身体约束的儿童出现了各种并发症,例如,手臂和手腕约束导致水肿和发绀、食物拒食和烦躁不安。尽管还需要进一步的详细研究,但通过在土耳其的儿科病房更明智地结合教育和专家咨询,可以减少身体约束的使用。