Nerbrand C, Svärdsudd K, Hörte L G, Tibblin G
Uppsala University, Department of Family Medicine, Sweden.
Scand J Soc Med. 1991 Sep;19(3):154-61. doi: 10.1177/140349489101900303.
Geographical variations in cardiovascular mortality have been reported from Mid-Sweden. IHD mortality for men aged 45-64 was 60% higher in the western part than in the east. Mortality from stroke for men aged 45-74 was 73% higher on the west. Similar differences were found for women. One possible explanation could be that there are no incidence differences but that the mortality differences are due to different survival rates or to differences certifying the cause of death. These two possible explanations were tested in this study. Data for all patients hospitalised during the 10-year period 1972-1981 for myocardial infarction or stroke in a high mortality area, the County of Värmland in the west, and a low mortality area, the County of Uppsala in the east, were collected. In addition, a substudy was performed where the basis for the death certificate diagnosis was studied. The western area generally had a higher case fatality rate than the eastern. However, a larger proportion of the deaths the eastern area, occurred outside hospital, so that the net effect would be that the differences found were not large enough to explain the mortality differences. The autopsy rate in the western part was lower than in the east but since a larger proportion of the deaths occurred in hospital the rank order for IHD and stroke mortality between east and west was the same whether all IHD or stroke deaths were counted or only those considered the most well documented.
瑞典中部地区曾报道过心血管疾病死亡率存在地域差异。45 - 64岁男性的缺血性心脏病死亡率在西部地区比东部地区高60%。45 - 74岁男性的中风死亡率在西部地区比东部地区高73%。女性也存在类似差异。一种可能的解释是发病率没有差异,但死亡率差异是由于生存率不同或死因认证差异所致。本研究对这两种可能的解释进行了检验。收集了1972年至1981年这10年间在高死亡率地区(西部的韦姆兰县)和低死亡率地区(东部的乌普萨拉县)因心肌梗死或中风住院的所有患者的数据。此外,还进行了一项子研究,对死亡证明诊断的依据进行了研究。西部地区的病死率总体上高于东部地区。然而,东部地区有较大比例的死亡发生在医院外,因此最终结果是,所发现的差异不足以解释死亡率差异。西部地区的尸检率低于东部地区,但由于较大比例的死亡发生在医院,所以无论统计所有缺血性心脏病或中风死亡病例,还是仅统计那些记录最完整的病例,东西部地区缺血性心脏病和中风死亡率的排名顺序都是相同的。