Schroer William C, Diesfeld Paul J, LeMarr Angela, Reedy Mary E
St. Louis Joint Replacement Institute, Premier Care Orthopedics, 12266 DePaul Drive, Suite 220, Saint Louis, MO 63044, USA.
J Surg Orthop Adv. 2007 Fall;16(3):131-7.
Recent total knee arthroplasty (TKA) studies suggest a more rapid functional recovery with minimally invasive surgical (MIS) techniques. These studies often fail to disclose the percentage of primary TKA that underwent the MIS technique, raising the concern that positive clinical outcomes are a result of patient selection. This study evaluates the applicability of the mini-subvastus technique in one surgeon's consecutive primary TKA patients. The applicability was determined utilizing a computer record review to determine the percentage of primary TKA patients in which the surgeon utilized a MIS surgical technique. The mini-subvastus approach was applied to 99% of 732 consecutive primary TKA. There was no patient selection based on age or weight. Traditional TKA, utilizing a medial parapatellar arthrotomy, was more likely to be performed on patients with a diagnosis of traumatic arthritis and in knees that required stems or augments. Preoperative tibiofemoral angle and mean knee deformity were not predictors of which procedure would be utilized. Despite employing this new surgical approach in nearly all primary TKAs, there was no increase in the complication rate. This high applicability rate with the mini-subvastus technique obviates concerns that the positive clinical outcomes in these patients are a result of patient selection.
近期全膝关节置换术(TKA)研究表明,采用微创外科(MIS)技术可实现更快的功能恢复。这些研究往往未披露接受MIS技术的初次TKA的比例,这引发了人们对积极临床结果是患者选择所致的担忧。本研究评估了迷你股薄肌下入路技术在一位外科医生连续进行的初次TKA患者中的适用性。通过计算机记录回顾来确定外科医生采用MIS手术技术的初次TKA患者的比例,以此确定适用性。迷你股薄肌下入路应用于732例连续初次TKA中的99%。未根据年龄或体重进行患者选择。采用内侧髌旁关节切开术的传统TKA更有可能用于诊断为创伤性关节炎的患者以及需要使用柄或增强装置的膝关节。术前胫股角和平均膝关节畸形并非预测会采用哪种手术方式的指标。尽管在几乎所有初次TKA中都采用了这种新的手术方法,但并发症发生率并未增加。迷你股薄肌下入路技术的高适用率消除了对这些患者积极临床结果是患者选择所致的担忧。