Owens Barry M, Kitchens Michael
Department of Restorative Dentistry, University of Tennessee, College of Dentistry, 875 Union Avenue, Memphis, TN 38163, USA.
J Contemp Dent Pract. 2007 Nov 1;8(7):11-20.
Using scanning electron and light microscopy, this study qualitatively evaluated the erosive potential of carbonated cola beverages as well as sports and high-energy drinks on enamel surface substrate.
Beverages used in this study included: Coca Cola Classic, Diet Coke, Gatorade sports drink, Red Bull high-energy drink, and tap water (control). Extracted human permanent molars free of hypocalcification and/or caries were used in this study. The coronal portion of each tooth was removed and sectioned longitudinally from the buccal to the lingual surface. The crown sections were embedded in acrylic resin, leaving the enamel surfaces exposed. Following finishing and polishing of all surfaces, one side was covered with red nail varnish while the remaining side was exposed to individual beverage immersion for 14 days, 24 hours per day, at 37 degrees C. The specimens were evaluated for enamel surface changes using scanning electron and light microscopy.
Enamel specimens exhibited visual surface changes following immersion in the test beverages with Red Bull and Gatorade revealing the most striking surface morphological changes. Specimens subjected to Coca Cola Classic and Diet Coke immersion also displayed irregular post-treatment surface morphology.
As verified by microscopic evaluation, all test beverages displayed enamel dissolution in the following order: Red Bull>Gatorade>Coca-Cola Classic>Diet Coke.
本研究通过扫描电子显微镜和光学显微镜,定性评估碳酸可乐饮料以及运动饮料和高能饮料对牙釉质表面基质的侵蚀潜力。
本研究中使用的饮料包括:可口可乐经典款、健怡可乐、佳得乐运动饮料、红牛高能饮料和自来水(对照)。本研究使用的是无钙化不全和/或龋齿的拔除人类恒牙。每颗牙齿的冠部被切除,并从颊面到舌面纵向切片。牙冠切片嵌入丙烯酸树脂中,使牙釉质表面暴露。在对所有表面进行修整和抛光后,一侧用红色指甲油覆盖,而另一侧每天24小时、在37摄氏度下浸泡在各自的饮料中14天。使用扫描电子显微镜和光学显微镜评估标本的牙釉质表面变化。
牙釉质标本在浸泡于测试饮料后出现了明显的表面变化,红牛和佳得乐的表面形态变化最为显著。浸泡于可口可乐经典款和健怡可乐中的标本在处理后也呈现出不规则的表面形态。
经显微镜评估证实,所有测试饮料导致牙釉质溶解的顺序如下:红牛>佳得乐>可口可乐经典款>健怡可乐。