Rawaf Mustafa M, Kressin Nancy R
Boston University School of Medicine, MA, USA.
J Natl Med Assoc. 2007 Nov;99(11):1248-54.
Racial disparities in several facets of healthcare have been widely documented, showing that African Americans face disproportionately high health risks when compared to whites. With respect to hypertension, 40% of the > or = 36 million African Americans are affected. We examined the correlation between the patient-physician relationship and the racial disparities in healthcare. We hypothesized that increased physician counseling would lead to higher patient trust and, thus, a greater likelihood of having controlled blood pressure. Four-hundred-sixty black and 333 white Veteran Affairs (VA) patients previously diagnosed with hypertension were included. Patients with a systolic reading > or = 140 mmHg and/or a diastolic reading > or = 90 mmHg at a recent doctor visit were considered to have uncontrolled blood pressure. By using patient exit interviews (PEIs), we quantified the number of counseling behaviors performed by physicians. Patient trust in physician was measured by validated questions answered on a 1-5 agreement scale. Results showed no racial disparity in blood pressure control. While blacks were found to receive more counseling, whites reported higher trust. Controlling for sociodemographic factors, we found that regardless of race, higher PEI scores were associated with higher trust; however, they were also associated with uncontrolled blood pressure. The association of physician behavior with blood pressure was not mediated by trust. We were unable to make direct cause-and-effect conclusions because the measures were recorded from a one-time questionnaire. Future research should focus on uncovering causal relationships, allowing physicians to work towards ending the established healthcare disparities.
医疗保健多个方面的种族差异已有大量记录,表明与白人相比,非裔美国人面临着极高的健康风险。就高血压而言,在3600多万非裔美国人中,40%的人受到影响。我们研究了医患关系与医疗保健中的种族差异之间的相关性。我们假设增加医生咨询会增强患者信任,从而更有可能控制血压。研究纳入了460名先前被诊断患有高血压的黑人和333名白人退伍军人事务部(VA)患者。在最近一次就诊时收缩压读数≥140 mmHg和/或舒张压读数≥90 mmHg的患者被视为血压未得到控制。通过患者出院访谈(PEI),我们对医生进行的咨询行为数量进行了量化。患者对医生的信任通过在1-5同意量表上回答的经过验证的问题来衡量。结果显示在血压控制方面不存在种族差异。虽然发现黑人接受的咨询更多,但白人报告的信任度更高。在控制社会人口学因素后,我们发现无论种族如何,PEI得分越高与信任度越高相关;然而,它们也与血压未得到控制相关。医生行为与血压之间的关联并非由信任介导。由于这些测量是通过一次性问卷记录的,我们无法得出直接的因果结论。未来的研究应专注于揭示因果关系,使医生能够努力消除既定的医疗保健差异。