Griffin Ruth A, Polit Denise F, Byrne Mary W
Boston College School of Nursing, Chestnut Hill, MA 02467, USA.
Res Nurs Health. 2007 Dec;30(6):655-66. doi: 10.1002/nur.20209.
The purpose of this study was to examine whether nurses' recommendations for managing children's pain were influenced by stereotypes based on children's personal attributes. Three vignettes, in which hospitalized children's sex, race, and attractiveness were experimentally manipulated, were mailed to a national random sample of 700 pediatric nurses; 334 nurses responded. Responses to vignette questions indicated little evidence of stereotyping. Nurses perceived similar levels of pain and recommended similar pain treatments, regardless of sex, race, and attractiveness. Nurses, on average, perceived children's pain at levels consistent with the children's self-reports and recommended assertive analgesic and non-pharmacologic pain management strategies. The results appear consistent with prevailing views on providing adequate pain treatment for children.
本研究的目的是检验护士对儿童疼痛管理的建议是否受到基于儿童个人特征的刻板印象的影响。研究人员通过实验操控住院儿童的性别、种族和吸引力,设计了三个 vignette,并将其邮寄给全国随机抽取的 700 名儿科护士;334 名护士做出了回应。对 vignette 问题的回答几乎没有显示出刻板印象的证据。无论儿童的性别、种族和吸引力如何,护士都认为他们的疼痛程度相似,并推荐了相似的疼痛治疗方法。平均而言,护士对儿童疼痛程度的感知与儿童的自我报告一致,并推荐了积极的镇痛和非药物疼痛管理策略。研究结果似乎与为儿童提供充分疼痛治疗的主流观点一致。