Mor Ram, Kushnir Igal, Meyer Jean-Jacques, Ekstein Joseph, Ben-Dov Issahar
Department of Allergy and Pulmonary Diseases, Tel Aviv Sourasky Medical Center, Tel Aviv University, 6 Weizman Street, Tel Aviv 64239 Israel.
Respir Care. 2007 Dec;52(12):1753-60.
To determine whether breath sound distribution maps can differentiate between patients with pneumonia or pleural effusion versus healthy controls.
We recorded breath sounds from 20 patients conventionally diagnosed as having pleural effusion, 20 patients conventionally diagnosed as having pneumonia, and 60 healthy controls, of whom 20 served as a learning sample. All subjects were examined with a computer-based multi-sensor breath sound mapping device that records, analyzes, and displays a dynamic map of breath sound distribution. The physicians who interpreted the breath sound images were first trained in identifying common characteristics of the images from the learning sample of normals. Then the images from the 40 patients and the 40 controls were interpreted as either normal or abnormal.
In the normal images, the left and right lung images developed synchronously and had similar size, shape, and intensity. The sensitivity and specificity of blinded differentiation between normal and abnormal images when the physician interpreter did not know the patient's workup were 82.5% and 80%, respectively. The sensitivity and specificity of blinded detection of normal and abnormal images when the interpreter did know the patient' workup were 90% and 88%, respectively.
Computerized dynamic imaging of breath sounds is a sensitive and specific tool for distinguishing pneumonia or pleural effusion from normal lungs. The role of computerized breath sound analysis for diagnosis and monitoring of lung diseases needs further evaluation.
确定呼吸音分布图能否区分肺炎或胸腔积液患者与健康对照者。
我们记录了20例经传统诊断为胸腔积液的患者、20例经传统诊断为肺炎的患者以及60例健康对照者的呼吸音,其中20例健康对照者作为学习样本。所有受试者均使用基于计算机的多传感器呼吸音映射设备进行检查,该设备可记录、分析并显示呼吸音分布的动态图。解读呼吸音图像的医生首先接受培训,以识别来自正常学习样本的图像的共同特征。然后将40例患者和40例对照者的图像解读为正常或异常。
在正常图像中,左右肺图像同步发育,大小、形状和强度相似。当医生解读员不知道患者的检查结果时,正常与异常图像的盲法鉴别敏感性和特异性分别为82.5%和80%。当解读员知道患者的检查结果时,正常与异常图像的盲法检测敏感性和特异性分别为90%和88%。
呼吸音的计算机动态成像对于区分肺炎或胸腔积液与正常肺是一种敏感且特异的工具。计算机呼吸音分析在肺部疾病诊断和监测中的作用需要进一步评估。