Benschop Jackie, Hazelton Martin L, Stevenson Mark A, Dahl Jan, Morris Roger S, French Nigel P
EpiCentre, Institute of Veterinary, Animal, and Biomedical Sciences, Massey University, Private Bag 11-222, Palmerston North, New Zealand.
Vet Res. 2008 Jan-Feb;39(1):2. doi: 10.1051/vetres:2007040. Epub 2007 Nov 9.
We describe the spatial epidemiological features of the 6.8 million meat-juice serological tests that were conducted between 1995 and 2004 as part of the Danish swine Salmonella control programme. We investigated pig and farm density using edge-corrected kernel estimations. Pigs were aggregated at the county level to assess county-level risk, and then we investigated farm-level risk by giving farms a case or non-case label using a cut-off of 40% of pigs positive. Conditional probability surfaces, correcting for the underlying population at risk, were produced for each year of the study period using a novel kernel estimator with a spatially adaptive smoothing bandwidth. This approach improves on previous methods by allowing focussed estimation of risk in areas of high population density while maintaining stable estimates in regions where the data are sparse. Two spatial trends in the conditional probability of a farm being a case were evident: (1) over the whole country, with the highest risk in the west compared to the east; and (2) on the Jutland peninsula with the highest risk in the north and south. At the farm-level a consistent area of risk was the south-west of Jutland. Case farms tended to aggregate indicating spatial dependency in the data. We found no association between pig or farm density and Salmonella risk. We generated hypotheses for this spatial pattern of risk and we conclude that this spatial pattern should be considered in the development of surveillance strategies and as a basis for further, more detailed analyses of the data.
我们描述了1995年至2004年间作为丹麦猪沙门氏菌控制计划一部分而进行的680万次肉汁血清学检测的空间流行病学特征。我们使用边缘校正核估计法调查了猪和农场的密度。猪按县一级进行汇总以评估县级风险,然后我们通过以40%的猪呈阳性为临界值给农场贴上病例或非病例标签来调查农场层面的风险。在研究期间的每一年,我们使用一种具有空间自适应平滑带宽的新型核估计器,针对潜在的风险人群进行校正,生成了条件概率曲面。这种方法改进了以前的方法,通过在高人口密度地区进行有针对性的风险估计,同时在数据稀疏的地区保持稳定的估计。农场成为病例的条件概率有两种空间趋势很明显:(1)在全国范围内,西部的风险最高,相比之下东部较低;(2)在日德兰半岛,北部和南部的风险最高。在农场层面,一个持续存在风险的区域是日德兰半岛的西南部。病例农场倾向于聚集,表明数据中存在空间依赖性。我们没有发现猪或农场密度与沙门氏菌风险之间存在关联。我们针对这种风险的空间模式提出了假设,并得出结论,在制定监测策略时应考虑这种空间模式,并将其作为对数据进行进一步更详细分析的基础。