Lee Soon Young, Jeong Seong Hwa, Kim Jinheum, Jung Sang Hyuk, Song Keun Bae, Nam Chung Mo
Department of Preventive Medicine and Public Health, School of Medicine, Ajou University, Suwon, Republic of Korea.
J Med Screen. 2007;14(4):205-9. doi: 10.1258/096914107782912103.
To propose an efficient screening schedule for breast cancer among Korean women using the stochastic model in which the age-specific incidence rate was considered.
Female breast cancer data in the Korea Central Cancer Registry 2002.
The stochastic model was based on the threshold method, in which the schedule is determined by a pre-specified threshold value. The threshold value was defined as the probability of being in a preclinical state of breast cancer at age 40 years. The sensitivity of the mammography was specified as 0.7. Two models for mean sojourn time (MST) in the preclinical state were considered; MSTs for Model I were 2 (ages < 50 years), 3 (ages 50-59 years), and 4 years (ages > or = 60 years), and MSTs for Model II were 3, 4, and 5 years for the corresponding age groups.
The threshold method for Model I generated 19 examinations within the screening ages of 40-69 years. Each screening time was determined at ages 40.0, 41.6, 43.2, 44.8, 46.0, 47.2, 48.4, 49.6, 50.7, 51.7, 52.7, 53.7, 54.7, 56.2, 57.8, 59.4, 61.3, 63.1, and 64.9 years. The schedule sensitivity of Model I was 64.2%, which was higher than that (57.5%) of the biennial periodic schedule. Model II included 11 screenings between the ages of 40 and 69 years and also showed a higher schedule sensitivity, especially for women aged 40 years as compared with the biennial screening.
This finding suggests that the threshold screening schedule for breast cancer increase the schedule sensitivity by reflecting the age-specific incidence rate of a population.
使用考虑年龄特异性发病率的随机模型,为韩国女性提出一种高效的乳腺癌筛查方案。
2002年韩国中央癌症登记处的女性乳腺癌数据。
随机模型基于阈值法,其中筛查方案由预先设定的阈值确定。阈值定义为40岁时处于乳腺癌临床前状态的概率。乳房X线摄影的敏感度设定为0.7。考虑了两种临床前状态平均停留时间(MST)模型;模型I的MST在年龄小于50岁时为2年,50 - 59岁时为3年,60岁及以上时为4年,模型II在相应年龄组的MST分别为3年、4年和5年。
模型I的阈值法在40 - 69岁的筛查年龄段内产生19次检查。每次筛查时间分别确定为40.0、41.6、43.2、44.8、46.0、47.2、48.4、49.6、50.7、51.7、52.7、53.7、54.7、56.2、57.8、59.4、61.3、63.1和64.9岁。模型I的筛查方案敏感度为64.2%,高于两年定期筛查方案的敏感度(57.5%)。模型II在40至69岁之间包括11次筛查,并且也显示出较高的筛查方案敏感度,特别是与两年一次的筛查相比,40岁女性的敏感度更高。
这一发现表明,乳腺癌的阈值筛查方案通过反映人群的年龄特异性发病率提高了筛查方案的敏感度。