Malik K, Benzon H T
Department of Anesthesiology, Northwestern Memorial Hospital, Chicago, Illinois 60611-2908, USA.
Anaesth Intensive Care. 2007 Dec;35(6):863-73. doi: 10.1177/0310057X0703500603.
Pulsed radiofrequency is a growingly popular pain treatment modality. However, its clinical efficacy remains controversial. In this review, the available literature on pulsed radiofrequency is critically analysed to determine its clinical efficacy. Our search of the literature for pulsed radiofrequency yielded 341 citations; after reviewing the abstracts we found 51 relevant articles. There were 4 review articles: 44 articles pertained to the application of pulsed radiofrequency by an electrode placed in the vicinity of a neural structure. Of these only two were randomised controlled trials. Of the remaining 42 articles, one was a non-randomised controlled trial, three were prospective uncontrolled trials: there were six retrospective studies, 11 case reports, eight laboratory studies, two position papers, five editorials and seven items of correspondence, while one publication reported two studies. Three articles pertained to transcutaneous application of pulsed radiofrequency. Of the two randomised controlled trials, one reported efficacy of the pulsed radiofrequency while the other reported it to be ineffective. The majority of the uncontrolled and observational studies reported clinical efficacy of pulsed radiofrequency, however many of these studies had limitations. Further randomised controlled clinical trials are recommended in order for the practising pain physician to clearly understand the role of pulsed radiofrequency in the treatment of various chronic pain syndromes.
脉冲射频是一种越来越受欢迎的疼痛治疗方式。然而,其临床疗效仍存在争议。在本综述中,对有关脉冲射频的现有文献进行了批判性分析,以确定其临床疗效。我们对脉冲射频文献的检索共得到341条引用;在查阅摘要后,我们发现了51篇相关文章。其中有4篇综述文章;44篇文章涉及通过置于神经结构附近的电极应用脉冲射频。其中只有两项是随机对照试验。在其余42篇文章中,一项是非随机对照试验,三项是前瞻性非对照试验;有六项回顾性研究、11篇病例报告、八项实验室研究、两篇立场文件、五篇社论和七封通信,而一份出版物报告了两项研究。三篇文章涉及脉冲射频的经皮应用。在两项随机对照试验中,一项报告了脉冲射频的疗效,而另一项报告其无效。大多数非对照和观察性研究报告了脉冲射频的临床疗效,然而这些研究中有许多存在局限性。建议进一步开展随机对照临床试验,以便执业疼痛医师清楚了解脉冲射频在治疗各种慢性疼痛综合征中的作用。