Kumar Raj, Kalra Samir K, Mahapatra Ashok K
Department of Neurosurgery, Sanjay Gandhi Postgraduate Institute of Medical Sciences, Lucknow, India.
Neurosurgery. 2007 Nov;61(5):987-93; discussion 993-4. doi: 10.1227/01.neu.0000303195.10544.79.
The assessment of response to treatment in pediatric patients with congenital atlantoaxial dislocation (AAD) is performed using a disability grading system but may be better determined by a score based on clinical parameters. This study proposes a scoring system based on a comprehensive neurological examination to assess surgical outcome in these patients.
Sixty-seven patients with congenital AAD aged 14 years or younger were included and analyzed prospectively. A scoring system based on six factors (motor power, gait, sensory involvement, sphincteric involvement, spasticity, and respiratory difficulty) was designed at the beginning of the study and all patients were assessed using this score as well as the Di Lorenzo's grade preoperatively, postoperatively, and at the time of each follow-up visit.
There was a very high incidence of occipitalized arch of atlas and fusion of the second and third cervical vertebrae in the irreducible variety. Most patients were classified in poor grades preoperatively; however, the changes in score were seen more often when using the scoring system we developed compared with the Di Lorenzo's grade. Our score also corroborated better with the clinical improvement.
The clinical profiles of pediatric patients with AAD are similar with a higher incidence of atlas arch anomalies in patients with irreducible AAD. A scoring system based on clinical parameters is proposed for clinical evaluation of such patients. This system is easy to use and interpret and is more sensitive to the changes in the neurological status of patients.
先天性寰枢椎脱位(AAD)患儿的治疗反应评估采用残疾分级系统,但或许通过基于临床参数的评分能更好地判定。本研究提出一种基于全面神经学检查的评分系统,以评估这些患者的手术效果。
纳入67例14岁及以下的先天性AAD患者并进行前瞻性分析。在研究开始时设计了一个基于六个因素(运动能力、步态、感觉受累、括约肌受累、痉挛和呼吸困难)的评分系统,所有患者在术前、术后以及每次随访时均使用该评分以及迪洛伦佐分级进行评估。
在不可复位型中,寰椎枕化和第二、三颈椎融合的发生率非常高。大多数患者术前分级较差;然而,与迪洛伦佐分级相比,使用我们开发的评分系统时,评分变化更常见。我们的评分也与临床改善情况更相符。
AAD患儿的临床特征相似,不可复位型AAD患者寰椎弓异常的发生率更高。提出一种基于临床参数的评分系统用于此类患者的临床评估。该系统易于使用和解读,对患者神经状态的变化更敏感。