Le Normand M T, Chevrie-Muller C
Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale, Hôpital de la Salpêtrière, Paris, France.
J Commun Disord. 1991 Oct-Dec;24(5-6):331-51. doi: 10.1016/0021-9924(91)90007-6.
The production of word classes in eight 53-62-month-old specific language-impaired (SLI) children was described and compared with that of 30 normal 24-33-month-old children in the same play situation. SLI subjects and nonimpaired children were selected within specified mean length of utterance ranges (low MLU versus high MLU). Production of word classes by subjects was evaluated in order to determine (1) whether SLI children showed a similar or a different word-class profile among themselves and when compared with non-impaired children and (2) whether MLU related to word classes would be useful as a single clinical index in assessment of language acquisition. Results showed that scores of SLI children in production of word classes reflect important individual differences among subjects. In the high-MLU sample, all SLI children produced each word class relatively within the same range as the nonimpaired group. In the low-MLU sample two SLI children were very different in their word-class profile and individual differences were further confirmed by a discriminant function analysis. Correlations between MLU and word classes were significant in nonimpaired children for all variables except Questions and Onomatopoeia and were only significant in SLI children for Verbs, Prepositions, and Personal Pronouns. Such findings contribute support to the view that there is "deviant" pattern of language in SLI children and once again questions whether MLU is one of the best discriminating indicators to use in the clinical assessment of language organization.
研究描述了8名53至62个月大的特定语言障碍(SLI)儿童的词类产出情况,并将其与30名24至33个月大的正常儿童在相同游戏情境下的词类产出进行了比较。SLI儿童和未受损害儿童是在特定的平均语句长度范围内(低平均语句长度组与高平均语句长度组)挑选出来的。对研究对象的词类产出进行评估,以确定:(1)SLI儿童之间以及与未受损害儿童相比,其词类分布模式是相似还是不同;(2)与词类相关的平均语句长度是否可用作评估语言习得的单一临床指标。结果表明,SLI儿童在词类产出方面的得分反映了个体之间的重要差异。在高平均语句长度样本中,所有SLI儿童的每个词类产出相对与未受损害组处于相同范围内。在低平均语句长度样本中,两名SLI儿童的词类分布模式差异很大,判别函数分析进一步证实了个体差异。在未受损害儿童中,除了疑问句和拟声词外,平均语句长度与所有变量的词类之间的相关性均显著;而在SLI儿童中,仅动词、介词和人称代词的平均语句长度与词类之间的相关性显著。这些发现支持了SLI儿童存在“异常”语言模式的观点,并再次质疑平均语句长度是否是临床评估语言组织时最佳的鉴别指标之一。