Hansson K, Nettelbladt U, Leonard L B
Lund University, Sweden.
J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2000 Aug;43(4):848-64. doi: 10.1044/jslhr.4304.848.
Several competing proposals have been offered to explain the grammatical difficulties experienced by children with specific language impairment (SLI). In this study, the grammatical abilities of Swedish-speaking children with SLI were examined for the purpose of evaluating these proposals and offering new findings that might be used in the development of alternative accounts. A group of preschoolers with SLI showed lower percentages of use of present tense copula forms and regular past tense inflections than normally developing peers matched for age and younger normally developing children matched for mean length of utterance (MLU). Word order errors, too, were more frequent in the speech of the children with SLI. However, these children performed as well as MLU-matched children in the use of present tense inflections and irregular past forms. In addition, the majority of their sentences containing word order errors showed appropriate use of verb morphology. None of the competing accounts of SLI could accommodate all of the findings. In particular, these accounts--or new alternatives-must develop provisions to explain both the earlier acquisition of present tense inflections than past tense inflections and word order errors that seem unrelated to verb morphology.
人们提出了几种相互竞争的观点来解释患有特定语言障碍(SLI)的儿童所经历的语法困难。在本研究中,对说瑞典语的患有SLI的儿童的语法能力进行了考察,目的是评估这些观点,并提供可能用于发展其他解释的新发现。一组患有SLI的学龄前儿童与年龄匹配的正常发育同龄人以及语句平均长度(MLU)匹配的年龄较小的正常发育儿童相比,现在时系动词形式和规则过去时屈折变化的使用比例较低。语序错误在患有SLI的儿童言语中也更频繁。然而,这些儿童在现在时屈折变化和不规则过去形式的使用上与MLU匹配的儿童表现相当。此外,他们大多数包含语序错误的句子都显示出动词形态的恰当使用。没有一种关于SLI的相互竞争的解释能够涵盖所有这些发现。特别是,这些解释——或者新的替代解释——必须做出说明,以解释为什么现在时屈折变化比过去时屈折变化习得更早,以及看似与动词形态无关的语序错误。