Berger Gregor E, Proffitt Tina-Marie, McConchie Mirabel, Yuen HokPan, Wood Stephen J, Amminger G Paul, Brewer Warrick, McGorry Patrick D
ORYGEN Research Centre (incorporating the Early Psychosis Prevention and Intervention Centre [EPPIC]), University of Melbourne, Australia.
J Clin Psychiatry. 2007 Dec;68(12):1867-75. doi: 10.4088/jcp.v68n1206.
To investigate if ethyl-eicosapentaenoic acid (E-EPA) augmentation improves antipsychotic efficacy and tolerability in first-episode psychosis (FEP).
We performed a 12-week, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of 2-g E-EPA augmentation in 80 FEP patients. Sixty-nine patients were eligible for analysis; a post hoc analysis was computed for a subgroup of nonaffective FEP patients (N = 53). The first participant was included in November 2000 and the last participant completed the trial in August 2003. Primary outcome measures were symptom change scores and time to first response, while tolerability measures and cumulative antipsychotic dose were secondary outcome measures.
Analysis of covariance controlling for baseline symptoms found no significant mean difference between E-EPA and placebo at week 12 for symptom change scores. Cox regression analysis revealed a significant treatment by diagnosis interaction (p = .024) for time to first response favoring E-EPA in nonaffective psychosis. Post hoc analysis for cumulative response rates further confirmed a higher response rate at week 6 (42.9% [15/35] vs. 17.6% [6/34] for all participants, p = .036; 54.2% [13/24] vs. 17.2% [5/29] for the nonaffective psychosis subset, p = .008); however, the difference at week 12 was no longer significant. Analysis of secondary outcome measures revealed that E-EPA-augmented participants needed 20% less antipsychotic medication between weeks 4 through 6 (p = .03), had less extrapyramidal side effects in the initial 9 weeks (p < .05 for all participants and for all timepoints), and reported less constipation (p = .011) and fewer sexual side effects (p = .016) than those treated with antipsychotic medication alone.
The findings suggest that E-EPA may accelerate treatment response and improve the tolerability of antipsychotic medications. However, it was not possible to demonstrate a sustained symptomatic benefit of E-EPA in early psychosis, possibly due to a ceiling effect, since a high proportion of first-episode patients already achieve symptomatic remission with antipsychotic medication alone. Further controlled trials in nonaffective early psychosis seem warranted.
Australian Clinical Trials Registry identifier 12605000267651 (http://actr.org.au).
探讨二十碳五烯酸乙酯(E-EPA)增效治疗是否能提高首发精神病(FEP)的抗精神病疗效及耐受性。
我们对80例FEP患者进行了一项为期12周的随机、双盲、安慰剂对照试验,给予2克E-EPA进行增效治疗。69例患者符合分析条件;对非情感性FEP患者亚组(N = 53)进行了事后分析。第一名参与者于2000年11月入组,最后一名参与者于2003年8月完成试验。主要结局指标为症状变化评分和首次缓解时间,耐受性指标和累积抗精神病药物剂量为次要结局指标。
对基线症状进行协方差分析发现,在第12周时,E-EPA组和安慰剂组的症状变化评分无显著平均差异。Cox回归分析显示,在非情感性精神病的首次缓解时间方面,治疗与诊断存在显著交互作用(p = .024),E-EPA组更具优势。事后分析累积缓解率进一步证实,在第6周时缓解率更高(所有参与者中,E-EPA组为42.9%[15/35],安慰剂组为17.6%[6/34];非情感性精神病亚组中,E-EPA组为54.2%[13/24],安慰剂组为17.2%[5/29]);然而,在第12周时差异不再显著。对次要结局指标的分析显示,E-EPA增效治疗的参与者在第4至6周期间所需的抗精神病药物减少20%(p = .03),在最初9周内锥体外系副作用更少(所有参与者及所有时间点p < .05),且便秘情况更少(p = .011),性副作用也更少(p = .016)。
研究结果表明,E-EPA可能会加快治疗反应并提高抗精神病药物的耐受性。然而,由于可能存在天花板效应,无法证明E-EPA在早期精神病中具有持续的症状改善益处,因为高比例的首发患者仅使用抗精神病药物就能实现症状缓解。似乎有必要在非情感性早期精神病中进行进一步的对照试验。
澳大利亚临床试验注册中心标识符12605000267651(http://actr.org.au)