Maillet J Peggy, Millar A Michele, Burke Jillian M, Maillet Michelle A, Maillet Wayne A, Neish Nancy R
Dalhousie University School of Dental Hygiene, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.
J Dent Educ. 2008 Jan;72(1):33-44.
The chair-side work posture of dental hygienists has long been a concern because of health-related problems potentially caused or exacerbated by poor posture. The purpose of this study was to investigate if using magnification loupes improved dental hygiene students' posture during provision of treatment. The treatment chosen was hand-scaling, and the effect of the timing of introduction of the loupes to students was also examined. Thirty-five novice dental hygiene students took part in the study. Each student was assessed providing dental hygiene care with and without loupes, thus controlling for innate differences in natural posture. Students were randomized into two groups. Group one used loupes in the first session and did not use them for the second session. Group two reversed this sequence. At the end of each session, all students were videotaped while performing scaling procedures. Their posture was assessed using an adapted version of Branson et al.'s Posture Assessment Instrument (PAI). Four raters assessed students at three time periods for nine posture components on the PAI. A paired t-test compared scores with and without loupes for each student. Scores showed a significant improvement in posture when using loupes (p<0.0001), and these improvements were significantly more pronounced for students starting loupes immediately on entering the program compared with students who delayed until the second session (p<0.1). These results suggest a significant postural benefit is realized by requiring students to master the use of magnification loupes as early as possible within the curriculum.
由于不良姿势可能导致或加剧与健康相关的问题,牙科保健员在椅旁的工作姿势长期以来一直备受关注。本研究的目的是调查使用放大倍率放大镜是否能改善牙科卫生专业学生在治疗过程中的姿势。所选择的治疗方法是手工洁治,同时还研究了向学生引入放大镜的时间对治疗效果的影响。35名牙科卫生专业的新手学生参与了该研究。每位学生在有和没有放大镜的情况下提供牙科保健服务时都接受了评估,从而控制了自然姿势的先天差异。学生被随机分为两组。第一组在第一节课使用放大镜,第二节课不使用。第二组则相反。在每节课结束时,所有学生在进行洁治程序时都被录像。他们的姿势使用Branson等人的姿势评估工具(PAI)的改编版本进行评估。四名评估者在三个时间段对学生PAI上的九个姿势成分进行评估。配对t检验比较了每位学生有和没有放大镜时的得分。结果显示,使用放大镜时姿势有显著改善(p<0.0001),与延迟到第二节课才开始使用放大镜的学生相比,在课程开始时就立即开始使用放大镜的学生的姿势改善更为显著(p<0.1)。这些结果表明,要求学生在课程中尽早掌握放大倍率放大镜的使用能带来显著的姿势改善。