Cade J, O'Connell S
Department of Community Medicine, University of Leeds.
Br J Gen Pract. 1991 Apr;41(345):147-50.
A postal questionnaire was used to assess general practitioners' knowledge, attitudes and current practice of treatment regarding obesity and weight problems. Overall, 299 responses (75%) were received from general practitioners randomly selected from family practitioner committee lists in Portsmouth and Norwich. Currently 27% of the doctors were overweight and a further 3% obese. Many doctors (69%) had tried to lose weight at some time and 40% had been overweight and a further 12% obese in the past. The most popular methods used to educate overweight and obese patients were one to one counselling and giving out diet sheets and leaflets on healthy eating. The treatment advice to patients from the majority of doctors was to eat less in general (78%) (specifically to eat fewer calories 75%); to exercise (77%); or to attend a slimmers group (54%). Doctors thought that they were less effective than the media or the family in persuading overweight patients to lose weight. Doctors said they were prepared to counsel on weight reduction but felt they had little success in achieving weight loss in patients. Experience was ranked as the most important contributor to knowledge about managing obesity, and medical school was rated as least important. Further study is needed to discover how different practices and attitudes affect patient management and which ones are associated with greatest success. Medical schools and postgraduate centres could play a more important role in educating doctors about nutrition.
采用邮寄问卷调查的方式,评估全科医生对肥胖及体重问题的治疗知识、态度和当前治疗实践。总体而言,从朴茨茅斯和诺维奇的家庭医生委员会名单中随机选取的全科医生共收到299份回复(75%)。目前,27%的医生超重,另有3%肥胖。许多医生(69%)曾尝试过减肥,40%的医生过去曾超重,另有12%肥胖。用于教育超重和肥胖患者的最常用方法是一对一咨询以及发放关于健康饮食的食谱和传单。大多数医生给患者的治疗建议是总体上少吃(78%)(具体少吃卡路里75%);锻炼(77%);或参加减肥小组(54%)。医生们认为,在劝说超重患者减肥方面,他们不如媒体或家人有效。医生们表示,他们愿意就减肥问题提供咨询,但觉得在帮助患者减肥方面成效甚微。经验被列为管理肥胖知识的最重要贡献因素,而医学院被评为最不重要。需要进一步研究,以发现不同的做法和态度如何影响患者管理,以及哪些做法与最大成功相关。医学院和研究生中心在对医生进行营养教育方面可以发挥更重要的作用。