Antonsson Per, Sundberg Anders, Kublickas Marius, Pilo Christina, Ghazi Sam, Westgren Magnus, Papadogiannakis Nikos
Center for Perinatal Pathology, Karolinska University Hospital, Stockholm, Sweden.
J Perinat Med. 2008;36(1):59-69. doi: 10.1515/JPM.2008.005.
To compare ultrasound (US) and fetal autopsy findings in 2(nd) trimester termination of pregnancy because of structural fetal anomalies.
A total of 112 terminations of pregnancy (TOP) between 1999-2003 were reviewed retrospectively. The cases originated from a secondary and a tertiary Fetal Medicine unit in the south Stockholm area, using a common specialized perinatal pathology service. Karyotype was not known at the time of US examination. The findings were compared and classified into four groups according to the degree of agreement between US and autopsy.
In 45% of cases there was total agreement between US and autopsy. In 40%, autopsy confirmed all US findings but provided additional information of clinical importance. Partial or total lack of agreement was noted in 11% and 4% of the cases, respectively. Areas of discrepancy involved mainly CNS- and cardiovascular abnormalities and, to a lesser extent, renal anomalies, abdominal wall defects and hydrops/hygroma. Regarding CNS abnormalities the overall rate of agreement was 62%; it was highest in acrania/anencephaly (92%) and lowest in hydrocephaly (39%).
We find an overall high degree of agreement between US and autopsy findings. Autopsy often provided additional information of clinical value and it should always follow US examination and TOP. Fixation of CNS is crucial for optimal results. Specific limitations of autopsy, i.e., detection of CNS abnormalities, may be reduced by complementary imaging techniques, such as MRI. The ability of US to detect cardiac anomalies is enhanced with the close contact to specialized fetal cardiology.
比较因胎儿结构异常而在妊娠中期终止妊娠时超声(US)检查结果与胎儿尸检结果。
回顾性分析了1999年至2003年间共112例终止妊娠(TOP)病例。这些病例来自斯德哥尔摩南部地区的一家二级和一家三级胎儿医学单位,使用共同的专业围产期病理学服务。超声检查时核型未知。根据超声与尸检结果的一致程度将结果进行比较并分为四组。
45%的病例中超声与尸检结果完全一致。40%的病例中,尸检证实了所有超声检查结果,但提供了具有临床重要性的额外信息。分别有11%和4%的病例存在部分或完全不一致。差异主要涉及中枢神经系统和心血管异常,其次是肾脏异常、腹壁缺陷和水肿/水囊瘤。关于中枢神经系统异常,总体一致率为62%;无脑儿/无脑畸形时一致率最高(92%),脑积水时最低(39%)。
我们发现超声与尸检结果总体上高度一致。尸检常能提供具有临床价值的额外信息,且应始终在超声检查和终止妊娠后进行。中枢神经系统固定对于获得最佳结果至关重要。尸检的特定局限性,即中枢神经系统异常的检测,可通过补充成像技术(如MRI)来减少。与专业胎儿心脏病学密切接触可提高超声检测心脏异常的能力。