Waylen Andrea, Stallard Nigel, Stewart-Brown Sarah
Health Sciences Research Institute, Warwick Medical School, University of Warwick, Coventry CV4 7AL, UK.
Eur J Public Health. 2008 Jun;18(3):300-5. doi: 10.1093/eurpub/ckm131. Epub 2008 Jan 17.
Parenting and parent-child relationships influence children's emotional and social development and evidence exists that they may be life-course determinants of health. This study tests the hypothesis that adverse parenting in the early years predicts poor health in mid-childhood.
A prospective study using data from the Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children cohort. Health data on over 8000 children (60% of those recruited) were available for analysis at 6.9 and 7.7 years.
self-reported maternal hostility, resentment and hitting/shouting in early childhood.
maternal report of child's health in general and number of health problems when the child was 6.9 and 7.7 years, adjusting for socioeconomic factors.
Sub-optimal parenting, as measured here, was observed among 62, 80 and 83% of families for hostility, resentment and hitting/shouting, respectively. Resentment was more common among older mothers in owner-occupied housing. Resentment and hostility predicted health at both ages independently of socioeconomic circumstances. 'Hitting/shouting' was weakly predictive of number of health problems. A greater proportion of variance was explained by parenting variables than by socio-economic variables.
Parenting and parent-child relationships in the early years predict health in mid-childhood in a way consistent with a causal role. If further studies replicate this finding, policies to improve parenting could be expected to have a modest beneficial impact on health as well as emotional and social development. As some aspects of sub-optimal parenting show reverse social class distribution, initiatives targeted at those living in social deprivation may not achieve the optimum impact on health.
养育方式和亲子关系会影响儿童的情感和社交发展,且有证据表明它们可能是健康的终生决定因素。本研究检验了早年不良养育方式会预测儿童中期健康状况不佳这一假设。
一项前瞻性研究,使用来自埃文亲子纵向研究队列的数据。超过8000名儿童(占招募儿童的60%)在6.9岁和7.7岁时的健康数据可供分析。
自我报告的母亲在幼儿期的敌意、怨恨以及打骂/吼叫行为。
母亲对孩子总体健康状况的报告以及孩子在6.9岁和7.7岁时的健康问题数量,并对社会经济因素进行了调整。
分别有62%、80%和83%的家庭存在本研究中所衡量的次优养育方式,即敌意、怨恨以及打骂/吼叫行为。怨恨在自有住房的年长母亲中更为常见。怨恨和敌意独立于社会经济状况,在两个年龄段均能预测健康状况。“打骂/吼叫”对健康问题数量的预测作用较弱。养育变量比社会经济变量解释了更大比例的方差。
早年的养育方式和亲子关系以一种与因果作用相符的方式预测儿童中期的健康状况。如果进一步的研究重复这一发现,那么改善养育方式的政策有望对健康以及情感和社交发展产生适度的有益影响。由于次优养育方式的某些方面呈现出反向社会阶层分布,针对生活在社会贫困中的人群的举措可能无法对健康产生最佳影响。