Frühwald Julia, Schicho Kurt A, Figl Michael, Benesch Thomas, Watzinger Franz, Kainberger Franz
Department of Radiology, Division of Osteoradiology, Medical University of Vienna, Austria.
J Craniofac Surg. 2008 Jan;19(1):22-6. doi: 10.1097/scs.0b013e318052ff1a.
In a retrospective study, distance measurements of nine children with craniofacial malformation were analyzed. The accuracy of measurements was compared when measured on a workstation using a 16-slice multidetector spiral computed tomography and on a stereolithographic model. Three different methods of defining distances were investigated: 1) on the stereolithographic plastic models, 14 distances connecting landmarks were identified with a digitizer (Polaris Tracker); 2) the same distances were defined at axial, coronal, and sagittal reformats of the computed tomography data set and measured using a Philips MX View workstation; and 3) the same 14 distances were defined at three-dimensional virtual reality models of the skulls at the same workstation. All measurements were performed with all three methods by three different readers. The following conclusions could be drawn: stereolithographic models provide a highly exact reproduction of the skull in children with craniofacial malformations. They are a reliable basis for all analytic and probatory endeavors preparing complicated surgical corrections. Three-dimensional virtual reality display modes serve significantly better for exact distance measurements on the complex surface of the human skull than planar reformats of the same computed tomography data sets.
在一项回顾性研究中,分析了9名患有颅面畸形儿童的距离测量值。比较了在工作站使用16层多探测器螺旋计算机断层扫描和在立体光刻模型上进行测量时的测量准确性。研究了三种不同的定义距离的方法:1)在立体光刻塑料模型上,用数字化仪(北极星追踪器)确定连接标志点的14个距离;2)在计算机断层扫描数据集的轴向、冠状和矢状位重组图像上定义相同的距离,并使用飞利浦MX View工作站进行测量;3)在同一工作站的颅骨三维虚拟现实模型上定义相同的14个距离。所有测量均由三位不同的读者使用这三种方法进行。可以得出以下结论:立体光刻模型能高度精确地再现患有颅面畸形儿童的颅骨。它们是所有准备复杂手术矫正的分析和验证工作的可靠基础。与相同计算机断层扫描数据集的平面重组图像相比,三维虚拟现实显示模式在人类颅骨复杂表面上进行精确距离测量方面显著更优。