McGlashan T H, Fenton W S
Yale Psychiatric Institute, New Haven, CT 06520.
Schizophr Bull. 1991;17(4):609-32. doi: 10.1093/schbul/17.4.609.
The classical subtypes of schizophrenia include the paranoid, hebephrenic, undifferentiated, residual, catatonic, and simple. This review of studies, especially those conducted during the last decade, supports the validity of the subtypes, particularly the paranoid subtype. To a lesser degree, the same holds for the hebephrenic and undifferentiated subtypes. The catatonic subtype has seldom been studied, perhaps because it is so rare. The residual and simple subtypes have not been the focus of any studies of note. Subtype criteria for DSM-IV are suggested based on the review. The paranoid and undifferentiated subtypes should be retained with criteria identical to those in DSM-III-R. The disorganized subtype also should be retained but with modified criteria that are somewhat more stringent than those in DSM-III-R. Catatonia and residual schizophrenia should remain, but insufficient data exist upon which to base any changes in criteria. Given its historical precedence, as well as the emerging importance of deficit processes in schizophrenia, simple schizophrenia should be renamed and reintroduced as a subtype in DSM-IV. Two variations in criteria are offered.
精神分裂症的经典亚型包括偏执型、青春型、未分化型、残留型、紧张型和单纯型。对各项研究的综述,尤其是过去十年间开展的研究,支持了这些亚型的有效性,特别是偏执型。在较小程度上,青春型和未分化型也是如此。紧张型亚型很少被研究,可能是因为它非常罕见。残留型和单纯型尚未成为任何重要研究的焦点。基于该综述提出了《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第四版(DSM-IV)的亚型标准。偏执型和未分化型应按照与《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第三版修订本(DSM-III-R)相同的标准予以保留。紊乱型也应保留,但要修改标准,使其比DSM-III-R中的标准更为严格。紧张症和残留型精神分裂症应保留,但缺乏足够数据作为修改标准的依据。鉴于其历史沿革,以及缺陷过程在精神分裂症中日益重要,单纯型精神分裂症应重新命名,并作为一种亚型重新纳入DSM-IV。文中给出了两种标准变体。