Santamaria Francesca, De Stefano Sara, Montella Silvia, Barbarano Federico, Iacotucci Paola, Ciccarelli Roberto, Sofia Matteo, Maniscalco Mauro
Department of Pediatrics, Federico II University, Naples, Italy.
Med Sci Monit. 2008 Feb;14(2):CR80-85.
Several studies reported low nasal nitric oxide (nNO) levels in subjects with primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD) and proposed nNO measurement as a diagnostic tool to screen for the disease. All these reports used the aspiration nNO method. The goal of this study was to evaluate nNO in patients with PCD using different methods of NO measurement, including continuous aspiration, silent exhalation, and single-breath humming exhalation, which increases NO wash-out from the paranasal sinuses to the nose.
MATERIAL/METHODS: Fourteen patients with established diagnosis of PCD and 14 healthy controls (HC) were examined. Oral and nasal NO levels were measured by chemiluminescence. Each subject performed NO measurement in triplicate during oral exhalation, nasal aspiration (nNOasp), nasal exhalation (nNOexh), and single-breath humming (nNOhum).
The median nNOasp value (95% confidence interval) was 11.6 (7.2-19.1) ppb in PCD and 321.8 (270.6-510.6) ppb in HC (p<0.001). The nNOexh value was 2.2 (1.3-3.1) in PCD and 31.8 (26.6-47.2) ppb in HC (p<0.001). Patients with PCD had lower nNO than HC during the last 80% of the exhalation throughout humming, i.e. 2.8 (2.2-4.3) ppb vs. 212.4 (158.7-244.8) ppb (p<0.001), and did not show a clear nNO peak. All nasal NO measurements had excellent specificity and sensitivity in detecting PCD compared with the healthy controls.
nNO is consistently low in PCD with good specificity and sensitivity whatever the method used for NO measurement. The extremely low levels of nNO during humming support the notion that NO is defective in the paranasal sinuses in PCD.
多项研究报告称,原发性纤毛运动障碍(PCD)患者的鼻腔一氧化氮(nNO)水平较低,并提出将nNO测量作为筛查该疾病的诊断工具。所有这些报告都使用了抽吸法测量nNO。本研究的目的是使用不同的NO测量方法评估PCD患者的nNO,包括连续抽吸、安静呼气和单呼吸哼唱呼气,后者可增加从鼻窦到鼻腔的NO排出量。
材料/方法:对14例确诊为PCD的患者和14名健康对照者(HC)进行了检查。通过化学发光法测量口腔和鼻腔的NO水平。每位受试者在口腔呼气、鼻腔抽吸(nNOasp)、鼻腔呼气(nNOexh)和单呼吸哼唱(nNOhum)过程中重复测量三次NO。
PCD患者的nNOasp中位数(95%置信区间)为11.6(7.2 - 19.1)ppb,HC为321.8(270.6 - 510.6)ppb(p<0.001)。PCD患者的nNOexh值为2.2(1.3 - 3.1)ppb,HC为31.8(26.6 - 47.2)ppb(p<0.001)。在哼唱呼气的最后80%过程中,PCD患者的nNO低于HC,即2.8(2.2 - 4.3)ppb对212.4(158.7 - 244.8)ppb(p<0.001),且未显示出明显的nNO峰值。与健康对照相比,所有鼻腔NO测量在检测PCD方面具有出色的特异性和敏感性。
无论采用何种NO测量方法,PCD患者的nNO始终较低,具有良好的特异性和敏感性。哼唱过程中nNO极低水平支持了PCD患者鼻窦中NO存在缺陷的观点。