Balayiannis George, Balayiannis Panos
Laboratory of Chemical Control of Pesticides and Laboratory of Pollution Control of the Environment by Pesticides, Benaki Phytophathological Institute,151 46, Kifissia, Greece,
Arch Environ Contam Toxicol. 2008 Oct;55(3):462-70. doi: 10.1007/s00244-007-9126-x. Epub 2008 Jan 30.
The pollution of six agricultural areas of Greece (north, central, south) by insecticides used in crop protection has been investigated utilizing, as a bioindicator, bee honey produced in those areas. Honey samples collected randomly from apiaries located in those areas were analyzed for pesticide residues with a multianalytical method, able to determine simultaneously up to 10 organophosphorous insecticides from the same honey extract. Findings concerning the acaricide coumaphos were also included, even though it is not used in crop protection. Coumaphos is used to control the mite Varroa destructor, an external parasite of the honeybee. The above areas are cultivated in large extent with citrus trees or cotton or sunflower crops, which are good forages for honeybees. The main pests of those crops are insects; hence, insecticides are used on a large scale for crop protection. The most contaminated samples originated from citrus groves; 16 out of 19 had pesticide residues: 4 samples had chlorfenvinphos (21.05%), 10 had chlorpyrifos (52.63%) and 2 had phorate (10.53%). Out of 17 samples from cotton fields, residues were found in 8, phorate in 6 (35.29%), chlorfenvinphos in 1 (5.88%), and chlorpyrifos in 1 (5.88%). Out of nine samples from fields of sunflower, four had phorate residues (44.44%). In brief, from the 50 analyzed samples, residues of chlorfenvinphos were detected in 5 samples (10%), residues of chlorpyrifos in 11 samples (22%), and residues of phorate in 12 samples (24%). Their levels ranged between 0.70 and 0.89 microg/kg. Coumaphos residues ranged from 0.10 up to 4.80 microg/kg and were derived exclusively from beehives treated with Perizin (the commercial formulation of coumaphos) for Varroa control. This study indicates that in agricultural areas with developed apiculture, useful information about the occurrence and the distribution of pesticide residues due to crop protection treatments can be derived from the analysis of randomly collected honey samples, used as bioindicators. It also shows that, very often, the chemicals used by apiculturists inside the hives in order to control disease are the main pollutants of the produced honey.
利用希腊六个农业区(北部、中部、南部)生产的蜂蜜作为生物指示剂,对这些地区作物保护中使用的杀虫剂造成的污染情况进行了调查。从位于这些地区的养蜂场随机采集蜂蜜样本,采用多分析方法分析其中的农药残留,该方法能够同时测定同一蜂蜜提取物中的多达10种有机磷杀虫剂。研究结果还包括杀螨剂蝇毒磷,尽管它未用于作物保护。蝇毒磷用于控制蜜蜂的体外寄生虫——狄斯瓦螨。上述地区大面积种植柑橘树、棉花或向日葵作物,这些都是蜜蜂的优质蜜源。这些作物的主要害虫是昆虫,因此大量使用杀虫剂进行作物保护。污染最严重的样本来自柑橘园;19个样本中有16个含有农药残留:4个样本含有毒虫畏(21.05%),10个样本含有毒死蜱(52.63%),2个样本含有甲拌磷(10.53%)。在17个棉田样本中,8个检测到残留,6个含有甲拌磷(35.29%),1个含有毒虫畏(5.88%),1个含有毒死蜱(5.88%)。在9个向日葵田样本中,4个含有甲拌磷残留(44.44%)。简而言之,在50个分析样本中,5个样本检测到毒虫畏残留(10%),11个样本检测到毒死蜱残留(22%),12个样本检测到甲拌磷残留(24%)。它们的含量在0.70至0.89微克/千克之间。蝇毒磷残留量在0.10至4.80微克/千克之间,且仅来自用Perizin(蝇毒磷的商业制剂)处理过以控制狄斯瓦螨的蜂箱。这项研究表明,在养蜂业发达的农业地区,通过分析随机采集的作为生物指示剂的蜂蜜样本,可以获得有关作物保护处理导致的农药残留的发生和分布的有用信息。研究还表明,养蜂人在蜂箱内用于控制疾病的化学品常常是所生产蜂蜜的主要污染物。