van Assen H C, Egmont-Petersen M, Reiber J H C
Dept. of Radiol., Leiden Univ. Med. Center, Netherlands.
IEEE Trans Image Process. 2002;11(12):1379-84. doi: 10.1109/TIP.2002.806250.
A widely used subpixel precision estimate of an object center is the weighted center of gravity (COG). We derive three maximum-likelihood estimators for the variance of the two-dimensional (2-D) COG as a function of the noise in the image. We assume that the noise is additive, Gaussian distributed and independent between neighboring pixels. Repeated experiments using 2500 generated 2-D bell-shaped markers superimposed with an increasing amount of Gaussian noise were performed, to compare the three approximations. The error of the most exact approximative variance estimate with respect to true variance was always less than 5% of the latter. This deviation decreases with increasing signal-to-noise ratio. Our second approximation to the variance estimate performed better than the third approximation, which was originally presented by Oron et al. by up to a factor approximately 10. The difference in performance between these two approximations increased with an increasing misplacement of the window in which the COG was calculated with respect to the real COG.
一种广泛使用的物体中心亚像素精度估计方法是加权重心(COG)。我们推导了二维(2-D)COG方差的三个最大似然估计量,它们是图像噪声的函数。我们假设噪声是加性的、高斯分布的且相邻像素之间相互独立。使用叠加了逐渐增加的高斯噪声的2500个生成的二维钟形标记进行了重复实验,以比较这三种近似方法。最精确的近似方差估计相对于真实方差的误差始终小于后者的5%。这种偏差随着信噪比的增加而减小。我们对方差估计的第二种近似方法比最初由奥伦等人提出的第三种近似方法表现更好,性能提升高达约10倍。这两种近似方法之间的性能差异随着计算COG的窗口相对于真实COG的错位增加而增大。