Taggu Wasing, Topham Ann, Hart Leslie, Carr-White Gerald, Sulke Neil, Patel Nikhil R, Lloyd Guy
East Sussex NHS Trust, Eastbourne District General Hospital UK, Eastbourne, East Sussex, United Kingdom.
Int J Cardiol. 2009 Feb 20;132(2):240-3. doi: 10.1016/j.ijcard.2007.11.076. Epub 2008 Feb 5.
This study describes the effect of introducing a cardiac sonographer led follow up clinic for patients with stable heart valve disease. The 2 years before and after the instigation of the valve clinic were audited.
The clinic was conducted in a single centre and undertaken in the cardiology department of a district general hospital. 382 patients, with 397 clinically significant valve lesions, but for whom surgery was not yet indicated but follow up required, were seen in a cardiac sonographer run clinics. These patients no longer attended a medical follow up clinic unless there was clinical or echocardiographic deterioration. Effectiveness was judged by the percentage treated according to current best practice guidelines, the number of echocardiograms performed and the number of hospital out patient visits attended. In addition mortality data for the subjects in the clinic was collected.
The proportion followed up according to best practice guidelines rose from 157 (41%) to 354 (92%) (p<0.01). The total number of echocardiograms performed fell from 807 to 550. Total number of out patient visits fell from 998 to 31. 11 patients died in the two year study period, none from progressive valve disease.
This study demonstrates that a protocol driven sonographer led heart valve disease follow up clinic, significantly improved the quality of follow up while bringing about a major reduction in out patients visits, without compromising patient safety.
本研究描述了为患有稳定心脏瓣膜疾病的患者引入由心脏超声检查技师主导的随访诊所的效果。对瓣膜诊所设立前后的两年进行了审核。
该诊所于一家区级综合医院的心脏病科在单一中心开展。382例患者有397处具有临床意义的瓣膜病变,这些患者暂未被建议手术但需要随访,他们在由心脏超声检查技师开设的诊所接受诊治。除非出现临床或超声心动图检查结果恶化,这些患者不再前往医学随访诊所。通过按照当前最佳实践指南接受治疗的患者百分比、进行的超声心动图检查数量以及门诊就诊次数来判断有效性。此外,还收集了诊所内受试者的死亡率数据。
按照最佳实践指南进行随访的比例从157例(41%)升至354例(92%)(p<0.01)。超声心动图检查的总数从807次降至550次。门诊就诊总数从998次降至31次。在为期两年的研究期间,11例患者死亡,无一例死于进行性瓣膜疾病。
本研究表明,由协议驱动、由超声检查技师主导的心脏瓣膜疾病随访诊所显著提高了随访质量,同时大幅减少了门诊就诊次数,且不影响患者安全。