Cook Joan M, Weingardt Kenneth R, Jaszka Jacqueline, Wiesner Michael
Department of Psychiatry, Yale University School of Medicine, West Haven, CT 06516, USA.
J Clin Psychol. 2008 Mar;64(3):296-307. doi: 10.1002/jclp.20458.
This study involved a content analysis of 261 unique advertisements for psychotherapy workshops that appeared in two bimonthly clinical magazines, Psychotherapy Networker and Counselor, during a 2-year period. Two independent judges coded each advertisement and documented the type and prevalence of advertising appeals used. From the seminal diffusion of innovations model, Rogers' (2003) five perceived characteristics of innovations found to influence adoption in diverse fields were not well represented in these workshops appeals, appearing less than 10% each. Few advertisements cited specific empirically supported treatments or presented any evidence of treatment effectiveness beyond expert testimonials. The most frequently noted appeals were to benefit the clinician (e.g., earning education credit or developing skills), characteristics that enhance credibility of the workshop (e.g., reference to storied history or mention of faculty), and features of the advertisements itself (e.g., use of superlatives and exclamation points). Promotional strategies to advertise psychotherapy workshops can be used to inform the dissemination of empirically supported treatments.
本研究对在两年时间里出现在两本双月刊临床杂志《心理治疗网络》和《咨询师》上的261则独特的心理治疗工作坊广告进行了内容分析。两名独立评委对每则广告进行编码,并记录所使用的广告诉求的类型和普遍性。根据创新扩散的开创性模型,罗杰斯(2003年)发现的影响不同领域采用率的创新的五个感知特征在这些工作坊诉求中没有得到很好的体现,每个特征出现的比例都不到10%。很少有广告引用具体的实证支持治疗方法,或展示除专家推荐之外的任何治疗效果证据。最常提到的诉求是对临床医生有益(例如,获得教育学分或培养技能)、增强工作坊可信度的特征(例如,提及传奇历史或提到教员)以及广告本身的特点(例如,使用最高级和感叹号)。宣传心理治疗工作坊的促销策略可用于为实证支持治疗方法的传播提供信息。