McGregor B A, Butler K L
Livestock Systems, Department of Primary Industries, Attwood, VIC, Australia.
Aust Vet J. 2008 Jan-Feb;86(1-2):12-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1751-0813.2007.00249.x.
Body condition scoring is widely used for sheep and cattle but the practice is included in only one Code of Practice for the welfare of goats in Australia. There is no published scientific evidence to support or defend its use in the assessment of welfare risks to farmed goats.
The significance of stocking rate, grazing system, body condition score (CS) and live weight were investigated in explaining the risk of mortality of individual and flocks of grazing Angora goats from hypothermia following a severe weather event in April. This event occurred 5 weeks after shearing the goats. Angora goats and Saxon Merino sheep were grazed alone, or mixed together in equal numbers at each of three stocking rates.
There was no mortality amongst Angora goats provided they grazed at the lowest stocking rate even when their CS was < or = 2.0. Mortality in flocks of Angora goats was most related to the CS reached during the preceding 2 months. For flocks of Angora goats there was no mortality at CS > or = 2.5 and mortality increased sharply at mean CS < 2.0. For individual Angora goats, mortality increased as CS declined and stocking rate and grazing combinations were additive in effect on mortality. Grazing with sheep increased mortality of Angora goats at higher stocking rates. The individual goat mortality rate was not dependent on individual plot effects suggesting that these results are applicable widely. Live weight loss was not related to mortality rates of goats once CS had been accounted for.
It was concluded that CS and stocking rate were highly significant determinants of welfare risk in Angora goats.
体况评分在绵羊和牛中广泛应用,但在澳大利亚仅一项山羊福利操作规范中包含该做法。尚无已发表的科学证据支持或辩护其在评估养殖山羊福利风险中的应用。
研究了饲养密度、放牧系统、体况评分(CS)和活重对解释4月一场恶劣天气事件后放牧的安哥拉山羊个体和羊群因体温过低导致死亡风险的影响。该事件发生在山羊剪毛后5周。安哥拉山羊和萨克森美利奴羊分别单独放牧,或以三种饲养密度中的每种密度按相等数量混合放牧。
只要安哥拉山羊以最低饲养密度放牧,即使其体况评分≤2.0,也不会出现死亡情况。安哥拉山羊群的死亡率与前两个月达到的体况评分最为相关。对于安哥拉山羊群,体况评分≥2.5时无死亡情况,平均体况评分<2.0时死亡率急剧上升。对于个体安哥拉山羊,死亡率随体况评分下降而增加,饲养密度和放牧组合对死亡率有累加效应。在较高饲养密度下与绵羊混牧会增加安哥拉山羊的死亡率。个体山羊死亡率不依赖于个体地块效应,表明这些结果具有广泛适用性。一旦考虑了体况评分,活重损失与山羊死亡率无关。
得出结论,体况评分和饲养密度是安哥拉山羊福利风险的高度重要决定因素。