Valis P, Repko M, Krbec M, Nýdrle M, Chaloupka R
Ortopedická klinika FN Brno-Bohunice.
Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech. 2008 Feb;75(1):34-9.
Injury to the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) is relatively rare and, if combined with avulsion fracture of the PCL insertion site, it accounts for only a small number of knee injuries. This is why PCL avulsion fracture is an easily missed diagnosis resulting in knee instability and arthritis development. The aim of this study was to show the necessity of surgical treatment of these injuries.
Between January 2004 and September 2005, four patients with PCL injury underwent surgery. Three had avulsion fracture at the PCL insertion site, and in one the avulsion fracture involved also the intercondylar eminence. The average follow- up was 15 months, with a range of 5 to 20 months.
The diagnosis was based on clinical examination, plain X-ray and MRI results. After arthroscopic treatment of the anterior compartment, the posterior compartment was treated from the posteromedial and the posterolateral approach. Using a K-wire for guidance, a tunnel was drilled and the fragment was fixed with an absorbable cannulated screw. Postoperatively, the limb was immobilized in a rigid brace at a 20 degrees flexion for 4 weeks followed by passive exercise rehabilitation. Within 10 weeks of surgery full weight-bearing was possible in all patients. Outcome evaluation was based on clinical, radiographic and MRI examination shortly after surgery and at 3-month follow-up.
None of the four treated knee joints had any post-operative instability. The PCL was in a correct position and showed appropriate tension on MRI scans.
Today arthroscopically-assisted operations are preferred to conservative treatment or open osteosynthesis. An exact diagnosis is best made on the basis MRI examination. To fix the bony fragment, various techniques can be used, such as hooked nail, screw, K-wire or traction suture through the proximal tibia. The method used usually depends on the size of a bony fragment.
The advantages of arthroscopic surgery include faster healing and rehabilitation and less pain and trauma associated with the operative procedure. A readily performed arthroscopic procedure prevents knee joint instability and arthritis development. The outcomes achieved in our patients give support to the indication for surgical treatment in this kind of knee injury.
后交叉韧带(PCL)损伤相对少见,若合并PCL附着点撕脱骨折,则仅占膝关节损伤的一小部分。这就是PCL撕脱骨折容易漏诊,进而导致膝关节不稳和关节炎发展的原因。本研究的目的是表明对这些损伤进行手术治疗的必要性。
2004年1月至2005年9月期间,4例PCL损伤患者接受了手术。3例在PCL附着点处有撕脱骨折,1例撕脱骨折还累及髁间隆起。平均随访时间为15个月,范围为5至20个月。
诊断基于临床检查、X线平片和MRI结果。在前侧间室进行关节镜治疗后,通过后内侧和后外侧入路处理后侧间室。使用克氏针引导,钻孔并使用可吸收空心螺钉固定骨折块。术后,肢体在伸直位用硬支具固定4周,然后进行被动运动康复。术后10周内,所有患者均可行完全负重。结果评估基于术后不久及3个月随访时的临床、影像学和MRI检查。
4个接受治疗的膝关节术后均无不稳。PCL位置正确,MRI扫描显示张力合适。
如今,关节镜辅助手术优于保守治疗或切开复位内固定。基于MRI检查可做出准确诊断。固定骨块可采用多种技术,如钩钉、螺钉、克氏针或经胫骨近端的牵引缝线。所采用的方法通常取决于骨块的大小。
关节镜手术的优点包括愈合和康复更快,手术相关的疼痛和创伤更小。易于实施的关节镜手术可预防膝关节不稳和关节炎发展。我们患者所取得的结果支持对这类膝关节损伤进行手术治疗的指征。