Gumina Stefano, Di Giorgio Giantony, Postacchini Franco, Postacchini Roberto
Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, University of Rome La Sapienza, Rome, Italy.
Chir Organi Mov. 2008 Feb;91(2):93-6. doi: 10.1007/s12306-007-0016-1. Epub 2008 Mar 3.
The assumption that subacromial space decreases in patients with thoracic hyperkyphosis arises from sporadic and personal observations. The purpose of this study was to compare width of subacromial space calculated on radiographs and CT scans of a high number of patients with thoracic hyperkyphosis that registered on exams of healthy volunteers. We measured the subacromial space, using Petersson's method, on radiographs of 47 patients with idiopathic or acquired thoracic hyperkyphosis and of 175 healthy shoulder volunteers. Both groups were further distinguished considering gender and age. Females with hyperkyphosis were also divided in two subgroups: those with a kyphotic curve of less (24 patients) or more (19 patients) than 50 degrees , respectively. Subacromial space of all patients and of 21 volunteers was also evaluated using CT. Acromio-humeral space was less wide in patients with hyperkyphosis with respect to coeval volunteers of the same gender; in females and in subjects older than 60. Subacromial width of females with hyperkyphosis whose curve was more than 50 degrees was significantly narrower (p<0.05) than that measured on radiograms or CT scans of females with a less severe spinal deformity. Decrease of subacromial space may be attributed to less posterior tilting of the scapula and to dyskinesis of the scapular movement. Scapular malposition causes an anomalous orientation of the acromion that may contribute to subacromial impingement. Patients with thoracic hyperkyphosis greater than 50 degrees had a subacromial space narrower than that measured in patients with a less severe kyphosis. This suggests that subacromial width is directly related to severity of thoracic kyphosis. Because hyperkyphosis of patients with osteoporotic vertebral fractures may worsen over the time, subacromial decompression could give only temporary shoulder pain relief.
认为胸椎后凸患者肩峰下间隙减小这一假设源于零星的个人观察。本研究的目的是比较在大量胸椎后凸患者的X线片和CT扫描上计算出的肩峰下间隙宽度,这些患者在健康志愿者检查中进行了登记。我们采用彼得森方法,在47例特发性或后天性胸椎后凸患者及175例健康肩部志愿者的X线片上测量肩峰下间隙。两组又根据性别和年龄进一步区分。胸椎后凸的女性也分为两个亚组:分别为后凸角度小于50度(24例患者)或大于50度(19例患者)的患者。还对所有患者和21名志愿者进行了CT检查以评估肩峰下间隙。与同性别同期志愿者相比,胸椎后凸患者的肩肱间隙较窄;在女性和60岁以上的受试者中也是如此。胸椎后凸角度大于50度的女性患者的肩峰下宽度明显窄于脊柱畸形较轻的女性患者在X线片或CT扫描上测量的宽度(p<0.05)。肩峰下间隙减小可能归因于肩胛骨后倾减少和肩胛骨运动障碍。肩胛骨位置异常导致肩峰方向异常,这可能导致肩峰下撞击。胸椎后凸大于50度的患者的肩峰下间隙比后凸较轻的患者测量的间隙窄。这表明肩峰下宽度与胸椎后凸的严重程度直接相关。由于骨质疏松性椎体骨折患者的后凸可能随时间加重,肩峰下减压可能只能暂时缓解肩部疼痛。