Hyenne A, Jeanblanc G, Osseby G-V, Giroud M, Combier E
CERMES, CNRS UMR 8169 - EHESS, INSERM U750, Villejuif.
Rev Neurol (Paris). 2007 Dec;163(12):1215-26. doi: 10.1016/S0035-3787(07)78406-0.
Stroke is a worldwide problem with high incidence, mortality and disability rates. A Meta analysis by the Stroke Unit Trialist Collaboration showed that stroke units improve outcome for stroke patients. Stroke care should take place in stroke units which consist of a hospital unit or part of a hospital unit that exclusively takes care of stroke patients. European recommendations have been published by the European Stroke Initiative and French recommendations by the Societe Française Neurovasculaire.
We sent a questionnaire to French stroke physicians in order to establish the different types of stroke care for French inpatients.
About half the people surveyed answered (106/193) and we selected 74 responses in order to have only one response for each hospital. Thus, we analysed 74 responses from 74 different French hospitals, coming from the whole country. Of the 74 hospitals, 23 had a stroke unit, 21 had dedicated beds for stroke inpatients, and 30 had no specific care. We identified 5 different types of stroke units: those with intensive acute care and post acute care (8/23), those with intensive acute care that were coordinated with a neurology department (7/23), those with beds in the neurology department (3/23), one with three levels (emergency, acute care and post acute care) and one that shared intensive care with cardiology. Structures of 3 stroke unit couldn't be identified. We studied their conformity to the recommended guidelines and found that, in most cases, they followed them closely. We studied differences between hospitals with stroke units and hospitals without stroke units in terms of technical or human means. We founded only a few differences between these two groups in the advantage of stroke units over hospitals without stroke units.
We found major differences of organisation between different types of stroke units, but no differences between hospitals with stroke units and other hospitals. These stroke units are generally in conformity with the recommended guidelines.
中风是一个全球性问题,发病率、死亡率和致残率都很高。中风单元试验协作组的一项荟萃分析表明,中风单元可改善中风患者的预后。中风护理应在中风单元进行,中风单元是医院中专门负责护理中风患者的一个科室或科室的一部分。欧洲中风倡议组织发布了欧洲建议,法国神经血管协会发布了法国建议。
我们向法国中风医生发送了一份问卷,以确定法国住院患者的不同中风护理类型。
约一半受访者(106/193)回复了问卷,我们选取了74份回复,以便每家医院只有一份回复。因此,我们分析了来自法国各地74家不同医院的74份回复。在这74家医院中,23家设有中风单元,21家设有中风住院患者专用床位,30家没有专门护理。我们确定了5种不同类型的中风单元:设有重症急性护理和急性后期护理的(8/23),设有与神经内科协作的重症急性护理的(7/23),神经内科设有床位的(3/23),一个具有三个层级(急诊、急性护理和急性后期护理)的,以及一个与心脏病科共享重症监护的。3个中风单元的结构无法确定。我们研究了它们与推荐指南的符合情况,发现大多数情况下它们都严格遵循指南。我们研究了设有中风单元的医院和没有中风单元的医院在技术或人力方面的差异。我们发现这两组之间在中风单元相对于没有中风单元的医院的优势方面只有一些细微差异。
我们发现不同类型的中风单元在组织上存在重大差异,但设有中风单元的医院与其他医院之间没有差异。这些中风单元总体上符合推荐指南。