Kornreich F, Montague T J, Rautaharju P M
Unit for Cardiovascular Research and Engineering, Free University Brussels, Belgium.
Circulation. 1991 Dec;84(6):2442-53. doi: 10.1161/01.cir.84.6.2442.
Patients with acute non-Q wave myocardial infarction (NQMI) appear to have more jeopardized residual myocardium at high risk for subsequent angina, reinfarction, or malignant arrhythmias than patients with acute Q wave myocardial infarction (QMI). Unfortunately, conventional electrocardiographic (ECG) criteria have limited utility in recognizing NQMI.
The present study combines the increased information content of body surface potential maps (BSPM) over the 12-lead ECG with the power of multivariate statistical procedures to identify a practical subset of leads that would allow improved diagnosis of NQMI. Discriminant analysis was performed on 120-lead data recorded simultaneously in 159 normal subjects and 308 patients with various types of myocardial infarction (MI) by using instantaneous voltages on time-normalized P, PR, QRS, and ST-T waveforms as well as the duration of these waveforms as features. Leads and features for optimal separation of 159 normals from 183 patients with recent or old QMI (group A) were selected. A total of six features from six torso sites accounted for a specificity of 96% and a sensitivity of 94%. All lead positions were outside the conventional electrode sites and selected features were voltages at mid-P, early and mid-QRS, and before and after the peak of the T wave. The discriminant function was then tested on 57 patients with acute NQMI (group B) and 68 patients with acute QMI (group C): Rates of correct classification were 91% and 93%, respectively. Because of the possible deterioration of the results caused by ST-T abnormalities also present in other clinical entities, a second classification model including an independent group of 116 patients with left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH) but without MI was developed. Two additional measurements were required, namely, P wave duration and a mid-QRS voltage on a lead located 10 cm below V1. Testing the model on both acute MI groups produced correct classification rates of 88% for acute NQMI and 93% for acute QMI. Group mean BSPM were plotted for the three MI groups at successive instants throughout the PQRST waveform. Typical patterns for each MI group were identified during PQRST by removing the corresponding normal variability at each electrode site from sequential MI maps. These standardized maps or discriminant maps provided information on the capability of each measurement at each electrode site and at each instant to separate each class of MI from the normal group (N). Striking similarities were observed between the three MI groups, particularly at mid-QRS and throughout ST-T. The closest resemblance was between acute NQMI and old QMI. Discriminant analysis was also performed on the 12-lead ECG: The first classification model (N versus MI) produced correct classification rates of 85% for acute QMI and 70% for NQMI. With the second model (MI versus N or LVH), correct rates were 81% and 65%, respectively.
Diagnosis of acute NQMI and QMI (also in the presence of LVH) can be improved substantially by appropriate selection of ECG leads and features. Comparison of discriminant maps from groups A, B, and C does not support the concept of acute NQMI as a distinct ECG entity but rather as a group with infarcts of smaller size. However, pathophysiological and clinical differences between acute NQMI and acute QMI influence long-term risks and may define different therapeutic approaches.
与急性Q波心肌梗死(QMI)患者相比,急性非Q波心肌梗死(NQMI)患者似乎有更多处于危险中的残余心肌,发生后续心绞痛、再梗死或恶性心律失常的风险更高。不幸的是,传统心电图(ECG)标准在识别NQMI方面的效用有限。
本研究将体表电位图(BSPM)相对于12导联心电图增加的信息量与多变量统计程序的能力相结合,以确定一组实用的导联,从而改善对NQMI的诊断。通过将时间标准化的P、PR、QRS和ST - T波形上的瞬时电压以及这些波形的持续时间作为特征,对159名正常受试者和308名患有各种类型心肌梗死(MI)的患者同时记录的120导联数据进行判别分析。选择能将159名正常人与183名近期或陈旧性QMI患者(A组)最佳区分开的导联和特征。来自六个躯干部位的总共六个特征的特异性为96%,敏感性为94%。所有导联位置均在传统电极部位之外,所选特征为P波中点、QRS波早期和中点以及T波峰值前后的电压。然后在57名急性NQMI患者(B组)和68名急性QMI患者(C组)上测试判别函数:正确分类率分别为91%和93%。由于其他临床情况中也存在的ST - T异常可能导致结果恶化,因此开发了第二个分类模型,该模型包括一组独立的116名无MI的左心室肥厚(LVH)患者。还需要另外两项测量,即P波持续时间和V1下方10 cm处导联上的QRS波中点电压。在两个急性MI组上测试该模型,急性NQMI的正确分类率为88%,急性QMI为93%。在整个PQRST波形的连续瞬间,为三个MI组绘制了组平均BSPM图。通过从连续的MI图中去除每个电极部位相应的正常变异性,在PQRST期间识别出每个MI组的典型模式。这些标准化图或判别图提供了关于每个电极部位在每个瞬间的每次测量将每种MI类别与正常组(N)区分开的能力的信息。在三个MI组之间观察到显著的相似性,特别是在QRS波中点和整个ST - T期间。急性NQMI与陈旧性QMI之间最为相似。对12导联心电图也进行了判别分析:第一个分类模型(N对MI)中,急性QMI的正确分类率为85%,NQMI为70%。在第二个模型(MI对N或LVH)中,正确分类率分别为81%和65%。
通过适当选择心电图导联和特征,可显著改善急性NQMI和QMI(包括存在LVH时)的诊断。比较A、B和C组的判别图不支持急性NQMI作为一种独特心电图实体的概念,而更支持其为梗死面积较小的一组。然而,急性NQMI与急性QMI之间的病理生理和临床差异会影响长期风险,并可能确定不同的治疗方法。