Grob D, Namba T
Ann N Y Acad Sci. 1976;274:143-73. doi: 10.1111/j.1749-6632.1976.tb47683.x.
The neuromuscular block of myasthenia gravis has the characteristics of an antidepolarizing (competitive block), similar to that produced by d-tubocurarine in normal subjects: progressive decrease in muscle action potentials evoked by two or more nerve stimuli, posttetanic facilitation, posttetanic fatigue, inhibition of the depolarizing action of acetylcholine (ACh) or anticholinesterase compounds, and reversal of the block by ACh or anticholinesterase compounds. In myasthenic patients spontaneously recurring negative discharges were more difficult to locate in the end-plate zone than in normal subjects, suggesting that the number or density of functioning end plates may be reduced. The threshold dose of intra-arterial ACh that increased electrical activity was higher than in normal subjects; the duration of the increased electrical activity was briefer, and was followed by more depression of negative discharges than in normal subjects and by a greater increase in the threshold dose of ACh. These results indicate that the end-plate zone of myasthenic patients is less responsive than that of normal subjects to the excitatory action of ACh, and may be more readily desensitized by ACh. In both myasthenic patients and normal subjects the intra-arterial injection of ACh produced a prompt transient decrease in evoked potentials, attributable to depolarization of the end plates, followed by recovery (and in myasthenic patients by repair), and then by a more prolonged late decrease in evoked potentials, attributable to desensitization of the end plates to transmitter. This prompt depressant effect of ACh on evoked potentials was less in myasthenic patients than in normal subjects, and the late depressant effect of ACh was greater. In myasthenic patients the late block produced by ACh had the characteristics of an antidepolarizing (competitive) type of block, including inhibition of the depolarizing action of ACh and reversibility by ACh or neostigmine, while in normal subjects the characteristics were those of a depolarizing (noncompetitive) type of block, including little or no inhibition of the depolarizing action of ACh and lack of reversal by ACh or neostigmine. The differences between the late depressant action of ACh in myasthenic patients and normal subjects resembled differences in the effect of other depolarizing compounds, such as choline, succinylcholine, and decamethonium, and are best explained by differences in behavior of the postsynaptic receptor. The disease appears to be due to the presence of abnormal forms of receptor or to abnormal responses of receptor to the transmitter. The predominance of one or other form of receptor may determine the clinical state of the myasthenic patient and his response to anticholinesterase medication.
重症肌无力的神经肌肉阻滞具有非去极化(竞争性阻滞)的特点,类似于正常受试者中d - 筒箭毒碱所产生的阻滞:由两个或更多神经刺激诱发的肌肉动作电位逐渐降低、强直后易化、强直后疲劳、乙酰胆碱(ACh)或抗胆碱酯酶化合物的去极化作用受到抑制,以及ACh或抗胆碱酯酶化合物可使阻滞逆转。在重症肌无力患者中,自发反复出现的负向放电在终板区比正常受试者更难定位,这表明功能正常的终板数量或密度可能减少。动脉内注射ACh增加电活动的阈剂量高于正常受试者;电活动增加的持续时间更短,且随后负向放电的抑制比正常受试者更明显,ACh阈剂量的增加也更大。这些结果表明,重症肌无力患者的终板区对ACh的兴奋作用反应性低于正常受试者,并且可能更容易被ACh脱敏。在重症肌无力患者和正常受试者中,动脉内注射ACh均会使诱发电位迅速出现短暂下降,这归因于终板的去极化,随后恢复(在重症肌无力患者中还包括修复),然后诱发电位出现更持久的后期下降,这归因于终板对递质的脱敏。ACh对诱发电位的这种迅速抑制作用在重症肌无力患者中比在正常受试者中更小,而ACh的后期抑制作用更大。在重症肌无力患者中,ACh产生的后期阻滞具有非去极化(竞争性)阻滞的特点,包括抑制ACh的去极化作用以及可被ACh或新斯的明逆转,而在正常受试者中,其特点是去极化(非竞争性)阻滞,包括对ACh去极化作用几乎没有抑制且不能被ACh或新斯的明逆转。重症肌无力患者和正常受试者中ACh后期抑制作用的差异类似于其他去极化化合物(如胆碱、琥珀酰胆碱和十烃季铵)作用的差异,最好用突触后受体行为的差异来解释。该疾病似乎是由于存在异常形式的受体或受体对递质的异常反应所致。一种或另一种受体形式的占优势可能决定重症肌无力患者的临床状态及其对抗胆碱酯酶药物的反应。